Michie Vs Aish

[Magic777]

which one to pick

[bkp130]

I think i prefer Michie. The Dees traded for him and got him for a reason and has had a few pre-seasons.

I know Aish has played in the SANFL but it is a massive step up to the AFL

[vmac66]

I have both , but have michie on the field . .

[Toga]

I'd go with Michie I think, seems a pretty safe option. Although Aish is definitely worth a shot if you can squeeze him in as well, has played a few years of senior footy now and the competition for his spot has just gone down with Claye Beams injuring himself again you would think!

[HotTiges]

have both and expect both to score ok.. Michie just ahead

[Samsturmfels]

To tell you the truth i dont know much about Michie but i do know some things about About Aish
1. The brisbane lions lost a lot of young stars during the off season which should make it easier to be in the best 22
2. Claye beams is also injured which should increase his opportunity
So im picking Aish

[Vinny]

Michie easy IMO, Aish is good but Michie is a lock IMO.

[GoLions]

I have both, but would choose Michie if I could only have 1.

[Grufflez]

Will find out soon but i think Michie will score much better than Aish, both will play a lot of games.

[Fid]

I have both, but would choose Michie if I could only have 1.

+1

[Redbaron]

I have both but freo got rid of michie for a reason (eg Geelong got rid of Shannon Byrne too) Aish hoe me but I have both