whats better supercoach or dreamteam??

[nichw07]

whats better supercoach or dreamteam??
and why its better

[Alex7089]

Well they both appeal to different types of people. Personally I prefer the SC scoring system because I don't rate guys who get 30 possies but give 5 FA's and 10 clangers. I like to rate a players performance on how they affected the match. Other people who like their stats would prefer DT because that is what the scoring system is based on.

[ossie85]

Well they both appeal to different types of people. Personally I prefer the SC scoring system because I don't rate guys who get 30 possies but give 5 FA's and 10 clangers. I like to rate a players performance on how they affected the match. Other people who like their stats would prefer DT because that is what the scoring system is based on.

I'm actually a professional statistician and I prefer supercoach because of its scoring system. Capping the amount of points per match available (3300 or whatever it is) makes sense cos it allows you to compare players week to week, and over time. Unlike dream team, where you can't compare say Dane Swan with Greg Williams cos it is a much higher possession game now.

[Pav29]

Very Close Poll.I like Dream Team a lot more that Supercoach. I think Supercoachs scoring method is stubid.

[ossie85]

Very Close Poll.I like Dream Team a lot more that Supercoach. I think Supercoachs scoring method is stubid.

Stubid huh?

Dream Team's the simple method, SC is the smarter, more complex one. Sure, it is up for interpretation, but so is judging any player's ability.