D3

[Jezza249]

if hibberd is fully fit by round 1 which one should i get

[tor01doc]

Hammies are a b!tch - ask Cyril.

Simpson - proven scorer - ave over 90 6 years now and over 85 for last 8 years. Only missed 3 games in 8 years.

I should shut up now.  :-[

[RaisyDaisy]

Genuine coin toss

So gutted about Hibberd as he and Mitchell were my only two locks

Simpson now

[tor01doc]

You from Ballarat?

[Grufflez]

Genuine coin toss

So gutted about Hibberd as he and Mitchell were my only two locks

Simpson now

Having the same problem, had Hibberd at R2 and am having trouble finding a R10 replacement.
It will probably be either upgrade to McVeigh or downgrade to Grimes as i don't want to start Hanley or Malceski.
Better now than early season though i reckon.

[tigertops]

Got Hanley at d3.
But I think Simpson just ahead n safer

[lin2rondo]

Why not have both? Bother reliable, that is if hibberd is fully fit. Both consistent which is what you want in a premium defender.

[enzedder]

Both good picks. Had Hibberd until the hammy. Had Simpson too. Still got Simpson. Won't have Hibberd even if fit by R1 cause of the hammy. He might be okay. He might be fit. He might not have any recurring problems. But...probably safer with a fit Simpson.

[Regs81]

Got enright at d3

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 8)
Simpson and ATM locked.   :-\