Version 2 of team. Thoughts?

Started by benharris222, February 16, 2014, 04:42:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

benharris222

Defence: S.Mitchell, S.Thompson, A, Everitt, M.Suckling, K.Kolodjashinnj, L.Mcdonald ( T.Cutler, M.Fuller)

Mids: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J, Selwood, J.Bartel, D.Thomas, X.Ellis, A.Moribto, L.Dunstan (J, O'Rouke, D.Gartlett)

Rucks: Z, Smith, Sandi (C, Wood, Thurlow)

Fwds: Dangerfield, D.Martin, Franklin, J, Kennedy, J, Cameron, Higgins ( Honeychruch Taylor)

Cash $34, 600


Are my mids too strong up top and weak down bottom?
Take out a premier forward? Let me know!

Thanks for your time. 

johnnytheboy1

Backs: was last nights match a fluke foe Everitt and is 2 Rookies backmen a risk  i know Mcdonald is a lock not sure on the other 2.
Mids: Bartel is better off in defence or left out of your team completely.I don't think Morabito will play from round 1 i think he will see a few WAFL games before
Rucks: Rucks are too weak would look at very least HMAC  or Grundy as 2nd ruck.
Fwds: I would look at Kennedy Harris instead of 1 of Cameron, Honeychurch or Taylor.
The first 3 forwards i would keep.

Team is ok not the best but if you like it go with it.

I give it a 7/10

benharris222

Thank you very much! I'll look into the advice you gave me! Downgrading Cameron to Kennedy Harris will let me upgrade my rucks.

Thanks for your advice.

benharris222

#3
After changing up my team a little...


Defence: S.Mitchell, S.Thompson, J, Grimes, A, Everitt, M.Suckling,  L.Mcdonald ( T.Cutler, M.Fuller)

Mids: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J, Selwood, T, Boak, D.Thomas, X.Ellis, A.Moribto, L.Dunstan (J, O'Rouke, D.Gartlett)

Rucks: H, McIntosh, Sandi (C, Wood, Thurlow)

Fwds: Dangerfield, D.Martin, Franklin, J, Kennedy, J, Cameron, Higgins, J, Kennedy-Harris ( Honeychruch Taylor)

Cash $11,200

tor01doc

Don't get sucked into Everitt - watch his next game because he's not that classy usually, although a leopard can change his spots I guess. I just wouldn't lock him in.

Watch KK - apparently highly regarded and they've got a slot for him. If this is true, save some money up front to use elsewhere and reap the rewards later when you cash him in. No way is either a keeper.

Risky rucks. Wow - need big cohunas to start with those 2. Prefer a solid type like Goldy or Minson. Or maybe even NicNait who can score really high in SC.

Kennedy and Cameron aren't on my radar for various reasons, but Higgins is - go figure!  ::)

You sort of have to rob from Peter to pay Paul if you know what I mean.I just worry you haven't enough genuine 'keepers' in your starting squad. Your 10 - 12 non rookie non keepers will weigh you down with regards trades later.

Good luck.