Updated team, feedback would be appreciated, thanks lads.

Started by coleman_17, February 16, 2014, 01:19:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

coleman_17


nperera95

Def: Too weak. No suckling? I'm not a fan of starting two rookies on field either. IMO, get rid of Terlich and Everitt.
mid: like the midfield. Good to see that you have both ablett and pendles in there. Like the POD in Ziebell. He will step it up another level this season imo. Good to see that you have both beams and thomas well. See how all the rookies throughout their nab games and then begin to finalise the rookies.
ruck: Like the POD in McEvoy. Sandilands at a bargin price.
fwd: A little too weak. Wouldnt have Chapman as bombers will be careful with him this season. First team I've seen with Petrie in there, so another good POD. Interesting choice in Crameri... I personally wouldnt have him.

overall: You have a pretty good mids and ruck but i believe you should change your forwards and defense. Good luck mate :)

upthemaidens

 Looks like you are being unique for the sake of being unique.

coleman_17

cheers nperera95 
I'm liking Chapman can score triple figures in the past and his price being lower than usual due to his injury last year.

ANd I have faith that terlich will step up again this year fingers cross. And everitt was promising in his nab cup game  but we will have to see thanks for the feedback


And risk = reward ;) aha

tor01doc

Bartel's star is fading. Prefer McVeigh for that much coin. Or you could drop down to the next level of $$$def like Hanley, Hibberd, Thompson, Taylor who should all be there (in the top 10 defenders that is) to the end. You can grab McVeigh when your rookies fatten up and you realise the error of your ways.

Everitt - I would much prefer Suckling if he is selected. So much more to be made.

Terlich - not for me thanks. I'd rather start with a rookie and risk that much on say Waters when he gets going?

Prefer NicNait over McEvoy. Lobbe - Renouf is such a doof that Lobbe will play plenty of minutes.

No way Chapman. In out in out. Red green red green - warning warning.

Reckon either of Buddy or Pav would look good in your team. Surely you can squeeze one in.

Good luck. Dare to be different though.

shaker

Different team not to bad but it looks like as soon as someone has a good NAB game you put them in think you will just end up confusing yourself more but good luck anyway  :)