2nd crack, thoughts please gents.

[Ashmore62]

Backs: J McVeigh, S Mitchell , M Hibberd, D Swallow, M Suckling, KK, (T Cutler, M Fuller )

Midfield: G Ablett, N Fyfe, Cotchin T , S Thompson, D Beams, D Thomas, X Ellis, O'Rourke, J (Crouch, M,  Honeychurch, M )

Rucks: N Natitanui,  Daw, M , ( D Currie, T Nankervis )

Forwards: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, A Fasolo, N bock, L Taylor, ( D Garlett, J Impey )

Cash left $2500.

Thanks Shaker & Piccollo for welcome and advice.. I think balance is better now.. thoughts? Recon Bock is great value.. hopefully makes round 1..can adjust rookies after nab cup.
Cheers.

[ben_020285]

Backline looks great. I'm not a fan of Swallow but I know many are.

Midfield is unique but I wouldn't have Thompson in there. There is no chance that he will be a top midfielder this year so I would swap him out for somebody else. I think Marc Murphy has a lot more upside and is 28k cheaper. You've done well to fit in 5 prems and Dale Thomas but it has weakened your rucks and forwards a lot.

Daw just isnt a great pick and he may not even play round 1. Swap him out for Nic Nat.

Fasolo at F4 is very weak. Try to make him F5 and bring in a player around the 450k mark. Gunston and Pavlich are two good options.

So I would
- Drop a premium from your mids and bring in a rookie
- Swap Thompson for Murphy
- Swap Daw for Sandi
- Upgrade Bock to a fwd who could be a keeper (Pavlich, Gunston etc)

[Ashmore62]

Backs: J McVeigh, S Mitchell , M Hibberd, D Swallow, M Suckling, KK, (T Cutler, M Fuller )

Midfield: G Ablett, , J Watsn ,N Fyfe, M Murphy,  D Thomas, J Martin, X Ellis, J O'Rourke , (Crouch, M,  Honeychurch, M )

Rucks: N Natitanui, A Sandilands , ( D Currie, T Nankervis )

Forwards: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, M Pavlich , A Fasolo , L Taylor, ( D Garlett, J Impey )

Cash left $4500.00

Thanks Ben_020285..great call. Really liking balance of this side now.. If you have a look appreciate feedback.

Cheers.

[ben_020285]

Team looks great now mate. The structure is spot on. Excellent balance on all lines.

Sit on this til NAB Cup!

[tor01doc]

Yep.

One very small whinge - no Pendles.

Apart from that - excellent.

[Ashmore62]

Backs: J McVeigh, S Mitchell , M Hibberd, D Swallow, M Suckling, KK, (T Cutler, M Fuller )

Midfield: G Ablett, , J Watsn ,N Fyfe, M Murphy,  D Thomas, J Martin, X Ellis, J O'Rourke , (Crouch, M,  Honeychurch, M )

Rucks: N Natitanui, A Sandilands , ( D Currie, T Nankervis )

Forwards: P Dangerfield, D Martin, L Franklin, M Pavlich , A Fasolo , L Taylor, ( D Garlett, J Impey )

Cash left $4500.00

Thanks again Ben_020285 & Tor01doc..season cant start quick enough.. Cheers lads.

[carlton]

Great team

DEF: Not sure about hibberd could have another breakout season but dunno rest is fine

MIDS: Not bad would try to get pendles for watson and a must is dayne beams at his price and a good rookie option is mcdonald

RUCKS: Great put in thurlow as your rookie since bellchambers is injured hell get some games

FORWARDS: cant fault but you could replace fasolo for rohan to free up some cash to get pendles

overall 8/10 

check out my team

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,89373.0.html