Supercoach 2014: Rate for a Rate

[benno123]

Feedback and rates would be great, will return the favour and look at your side :)

DEF: Mitchell, Simpson, Hurn, Swallow, Suckling, Laidler
(Cutler, Fuller)

MID: Ablett, Fyfe, Cotchin, Beams, Thomas, Michie, Ellis, Dunstan
(Taylor, Honeychurch)

RUC: Lobbe, Sandilands
(Thurlow, Nankervis)

FWD: Dangerfield, Martin, Dixon, Franklin, Pavlich, Garlett
(Kennedy-Harris, Impey)

$1,900

[jackel82]

def- cant fault, Hurn is a great POD heard he has been training well.
mids- Id like to see one more super proven premo here. Big chance fyfe will become just that though. perhaps cotchin to watson or pendles. (at the cost of a fwd)
Rucks - pretty standard, cant fault really. I do like grundy a lot for his price, worth considering
fwds - Perhaps downgrade pav or dixon to a midpricer like fas to strengthen your mids a bit.
Good team with a couple of interesting POD, Love to have fyfe in mine.

cheers

[tor01doc]

Pendles.

A few too many maybe types - Suckling, Swallow, Thomas, Dixon, Pavlich, Michie, Sandi, Ellis and Hurn all in the same team sooty me.

Maybe grab one of the 'expensive' rookie mids instead of Thomas and get Pendles somehow.

[nperera95]

Def: Not a fan of Laidler but that's just me. Other than that, you have a pretty strong defense. Love the selection of Hurn!
Mid: A little weak I think. Need another premium. Perhaps a Watson/Rockliff.
Rucks: Standard ruck
Fwd: Very strong forward.

Overall: I'd probably downgrade forward and then use that money to get your Watson/Rockliff,etc. Other than that, it's a pretty good side!

[sammy123]

DEF: good. Great unique in hurn. Not a fan of swallow TBH.

MIDS: great. Very unique. Needs PENDLES. Also not a thomas fan either.

RUCKS: great same as mine.

FWDS: are great. Good pick in dixon. Hopefully pav can pump 100's.

Wont comment on rookies as wont know the good ones to NAB challenge is over