Nic Naitanui vs Ben Mcevoy

[blues123]

Nic Naitanui vs Ben Mcevoy

[Ricochet]

If NicNat gets through the rest of preseason, then him every day of the week. His scoring potential is far greater then McEvoys

[nrich102]

Sam Michael is better and cheaper

[shaker]

Nic Nat by a mile if he is fit which is looking less and less as the weeks roll by has not played since RD 17 last year and still only on light drills still seems to be having ongoing groin problems

[Mat0369]

I vote for Daniel 'Rhymes with Orange' Gorringe

[Toga]

Yeah if NicNat is fit then go with him as others have said.

I'm not sure about McEvoy, he does a lot around the ground which is good for fantasy numbers but some of the Hawks supporters somewhere on here were thinking that Big Boy is actually a chance to cop the red vest at times this year..!

Personally I'm not so sure they'll be able to afford to sub him off if he is their main man, and think Hale is the more obvious vest candidate, but worth considering!

[_wato]

Yeah if NicNat is fit then go with him as others have said.

I'm not sure about McEvoy, he does a lot around the ground which is good for fantasy numbers but some of the Hawks supporters somewhere on here were thinking that Big Boy is actually a chance to cop the red vest at times this year..!

Personally I'm not so sure they'll be able to afford to sub him off if he is their main man, and think Hale is the more obvious vest candidate, but worth considering!

Yeah I've heard that also mate, and considering the amount of times Max Bailey was subbed out, they might be spot on with at least one ruckman barring injuries anywhere else going out. Mcevoy isn't a very good 'ruckman' surprisingly but gets a few touches around the ground. If he could improve his hit outs and work on ground level, he could be a great pickup.