Geelong rucks

[thefuzz]

Who is geelongs #1 ruck? Is anyone looking at Simpson as an option?

[Toga]

I've heard talk of it being Simpson with Vardy set to be played more up forwards, but I would've thought HMac would probably be the #1 if he is fit (big if)

[Ricochet]

Yeh Simpson is the best tap ruckman there but he's injury prone just like HMac.

[Master Q]

Talent wise surely it's HMac, but Simpson has loads of potential.

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Wouldn't pick any of them unless HMac hits some form.

[Windigo]

H-Mac would have to be a lock if he plays NAB and suits up round one....

[T Dog]

H-Mac would have to be a lock if he plays NAB and suits up round one....

HHHHHmmmmm..... :-\

[pommyadam]

but will they be likely to play with a backup ruckman in the FWDs, could see reduced scores for HMac (see Freo as case 1)

that's the only thing that turns me off him (and potentially the cheapness of Sandi depending on what Freo do)

[Ziplock]

Blicavvvvs :P

[Jukes]

HMac is priced at an average of a bit over 65.

Not worth it when he stands to play 15 games at 75.

[thefuzz]

Personally I think Blicavs will keep his place over Dawson at least, and no way Geelong would go just HMac as a sole ruck. HMac and Blicavs would seem to be the combo they go with from my perspective though I don't know much about Geelong. Though I do really rate Simpson, but surely there isn't room for Blicavs, HMac and Simpson with Vardy and Hawkins there too?