Rate please

[cats32]

Feedback?

Goddard, Cornes, Lockyer, Adcock, Malceski, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Petrenko)
Judd, Ball, J.Selwood, Foley, Masten, Rich (Beams, Robinson)
Cox, McIntosh (White, Graham)
J.Brown, Chapman, Richardson, Hall, Houlihan, Higgins, Krakouer (Ziebell, M.Brown)

[TigerFever]

Brown coming back injury is a concern. My opinion is Ball isnt really a SCer and Chapman doesnt look as good as a few years ago other wise its a good side :P

[cats32]

Ball hasn't been fit for 2 years. His appetite for the contested ball (now fit) will take him to gun status IMO.
Can't agree with you on Chapman.
You are correct on Brown (re risk) but all rookies are a risk.

Thanks for the comments tho

[TigerFever]

Ball hasn't been fit for 2 years. His appetite for the contested ball (now fit) will take him to gun status IMO.
Can't agree with you on Chapman.
You are correct on Brown (re risk) but all rookies are a risk.

Thanks for the comments tho

But Brown is a 540 risk compared to a rookie at 120k and i can see your point on Ball. Still cant agree with Chapman he might play well but i wouldnt take that kind of risk.
Have a look at my team http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,929.0.html

[cats32]

Apologies, I thought you were referring to M.Brown (rookie) as the risk, not J.Brown

[Watto]

Interesting selection with Hall, but pretty good

[Cool9]

I think Chappy is in for a good year. Last year was very sub-par by his high standards, and he didn't look match-fit to me. He seems hungry to make amends this year.

[cats32]

Cool9, I totally agree on Chappy. As a Geelong fan, I can really sense it so far in his pre-season that he is up and about.

Watto, regarding Hall, I think he could just about turn out to be the buy of 2009 and so far he's under the radar

[Pink Pythons]

Brown coming back injury is a concern. My opinion is Ball isnt really a SCer and Chapman doesnt look as good as a few years ago other wise its a good side :P

Hear him Hear Him!

god bless
hugs and kisses