H shaw vs Enright / will I win

tigertops · August 29, 2013, 08:15:20 AM

In a cash league final and looking to upgrade duffield. Opponent has enright but not worried about pod just want best avail.
Have godd birch Gibbs Hanley r Murphy duff?? With Vlas bench

Also have jjk in fwds that I think I should upgrade.
Have Steve j dusty cox rocky bartel in fwds
Yep I have 2 trades left and cash. Hehe

After some opinions as to best options

Rucks Munson Maric
Mids GAJ pendles swan jelwood JPK griffin cotch Mundy????(maybe upgr him)

Thanks for the advise all

*********UPDATED***********

Unique players are
Me: r murph. Birch. Jelwood. swan jjk Minson
Him: terlich. Ibbots. Mitch grigg beams caff/ Mayes buddy
I have cox fwd him Ruck hence bud v minno.

Who will win?

Rusty00 · August 29, 2013, 10:31:47 AM

I wouldn't trade Mundy. Although he's unlikely to smash out a 130+ he is fairly consistent and is unlikely to give you a 50 or 60.

I would pick Enright over Shaw just because of the uncertainty with Shaw's role recently. With Ben Reid playing forward Shaw has been playing almost like a key defender at times and with North's tall forward line he could end up playing on someone like Tarrant or Black. He scored well last week because Collingwood were winning easily whereas I don't think that will be the case this week.

I think the Eagles will put in a better showing this week which could/should help JJK. Also Daniel Talia is in doubt for the game this week and if he misses I would keep JJK.

You're rucks are ok thanks to Maric's improved showing of late.

caluuum · August 29, 2013, 06:27:48 PM

Wait until the teams are released because theres a good chance Mundy is out anyway :(

Rusty00 · August 29, 2013, 06:43:09 PM

I've changed my mind, you should trade Mundy :P

tigertops · August 30, 2013, 06:53:57 AM

Quote from: Rusty00 on August 29, 2013, 06:43:09 PM

I've changed my mind, you should trade Mundy :P

Somehow I think ur right.
Now for trade 2 it's prob out of
Jjk to walker. Or
Duffy to enright

Ricochet · August 30, 2013, 10:02:18 AM

Duffman has to go mate. Freo have rested too many of their key defenders. He will play a lockdown role this week

Rusty00 · August 30, 2013, 10:05:40 AM

Yeah, agree with Rico.

Also I think West Coat will put out a better effort this week in comparison to the last 2 weeks and which willl help JJK get into the game more (at least I hope so as I have JJK :-\ )

tigertops · August 30, 2013, 06:32:58 PM

Thanks guys I think I'll have to go duff to enright

Unique players are then
Me: r murph. Birch. Jelwood. swan jjk Minson
Him: terlich. Ibbots. Mitch grigg beams caff/ Mayes buddy
I have cox fwd him Ruck hence bud v minno.

Who will win?

DaveElNacho · August 30, 2013, 06:54:26 PM

Quote from: tigertops on August 30, 2013, 06:32:58 PM
Thanks guys I think I'll have to go duff to enright

Unique players are then
Me: r murph. Birch. Jelwood. swan jjk Minson
Him: terlich. Ibbots. Mitch grigg beams caff/ Mayes buddy
I have cox fwd him Ruck hence bud v minno.

Who will win?

I like your chances. Especially if you VC Selwood. Just hope either Birch or JJK gets a decent score

tigertops · August 31, 2013, 11:47:47 PM

76 points up with one less player played. Oppo went JPK VC and now only has GAJ as real C option. I had jelwood VC and now have option of matching his GAJ C or going swan ( or pendles) C. Think I should match him and go GAJ C to negate the great mans ability to go massive and over run me.
Play it safe and I think
The two trades left vs his none (due to his last 2 round inj luck) have helPed me: Lesson for all keep trades for finals....