Grand Final of Cash League: What do you think for my trades? (pic)

[jamfrank]

So dis is my team.


I have three trades in mind at the moment:

i) Heppell-->Houli [bench Gibbs]

ii) Murphy-->Libba [who would I bench??? Cotchin? He could have a big one against the Dons (no Hocking!) and my opponent has Cotch)

iii) JJK-->Stokes or Pavlich [again, unsure on who to bench: N. Roo (vs Freo) or Bartel (vs Brisbane)]

I'll cheer for any good advice. Thanks peeps.

[popedelio]

I reckon leave your midfield, it is awesome.

With the defenders trading Heppell to a premo is a smart trade, you could also look at O'brien, Hibberd or Murphy. Then Bench Gibbs

Bring in Stokesy, he has been superb, then bench Bartel because NRoo has been super consistent this year. Where as Jimmy can be in and out of games, depends on how he is used.

[LF]

The Heppell to Houli one is ok  O'Brien Stanley and Adcock are other options and Gibbs to the bench is a good move.

I like your forwards JJK on the bench is the way to go
I'd go with your mid trade and bench Cotchin.

[jamfrank]

bump.

I'm still really struggling with this decision.

I'm locking in Heppell-->premo defender and bench gibbs (most likely O'Brien or Houli)

but what about the last trade????
JJK-->Stokes/Pav (bench Bartel)
OR
Murphy-->Libba (bench Cotchin)

[popedelio]

Out of Pav and Stokes I would choose Stokes over Pav

Well if we go by projection by dt gold

Bartel - 84
Cotchin - 92
Stokes - 95
Libba - 108

Doing the forward trade will give you 187 (Stokes and Cotchin), doing the mid trade will give you 192 (Bartel and Libba). Thus giving you a 5 point differential. If you think those players will beat there projection or go lower do a new calculation and pick the trade which will give you the more points :)