Cotchin vs Watson vs Marc Murphy

[jamfrank]

Which two would you field out of Cotchin, Murphy and Watson.

Watson
Been in great form after returning from injury. However last time he played Carlton he got tagged out of it for a 70. However Cachia who did the job last time isn't playing. Curnow is, and he managed to keep Stanton to a 51...will Curnow go to Stants or to Watson??

Cotchin
Apart from last week's 51, Cotch has been in good touch. Will he be tagged out by GWS or will he run rampant?

Murphy
Spudding it up left right and centre. Has not tonned up since round 11 (and in that round he only just hit the 100), but that was against the Dons. Has a really good record against them, and they're probably in their worst form for the season right now. Hocking will probably go to him, who managed to keep Boomer to a 70 last week, but let Priddis get a 107 the week before and Penlebury a 111 the week before that. He's the real question mark in this trio...will he score more than Watson or Cotchin???

[Ricochet]

Watson is an easy one for me and then I'm leaning towards Murphy. Only because I don't think Bomber have anyone that can keep Marc quiet. Cotchin should cop a lot of attention

[jamfrank]

It's still cotchin vs gws, though. Even if he plays up forward he's a good chance to bag some goals. Somehow it doesn't feel right fielding an 84 average player (Murphy) over a 96...

[Ricochet]

GWS kept him to 87 last year and Marc hasn't dropped below 100 against the Bombers in his last 5 games against them. 100, 163, 114, 119, 118 and his last 5 against the Bombers.

Although Marc has been down this year so I'm not 100% confident he will score more than Cotchin. More of a gut feeling tbh

[jamfrank]

Whiley's out for GWS...Think I might put Murphy on the bench

[smoothM24]

Out of those 3 I would put Murph on the bench. His form is just hard to look past.
My Dilemma is between Murph and ROK. Both of their forms are terrible, but Murph has better history against his opponent. TOugh one