Hanley + Sandi vs Roughy + Birchall

[Glort]

Sorry for taking up space with another poll, please take pitty and vote though :)  Is Birchall just to risky? Playing on Friday night helps......

[RoughRed]

IMO the Hanley-Sandilands combination is the way to go
Sandilands against the Melbourne Rucks AND playing forward is good for a couple of marks and goals like last week
Hanley has been playing high Half forward and in the middle ... good for possessions
Roughy will be solid
Birchall may go big but is a risk 1st game back ... could be the vested one !!

[Ricochet]

Normally i would say the Rough/Birch combo would score more but with Birch only just coming back I like the Sandi/Hanley combo

[Glort]

Cheers guys, it's just that I actually watched how bad Sandalands was last week  :-\  I won a final by 2 points and I'm sure it was the abuse I yelled at the T.V. that pushed him to get that 40 points  ;D
I can check before the game if Birchall will start sub....... but he may wind up subbed off like west coast did to Nic Nat.
I will still be pondering this tomorrow.....

[Glort]

Bump......
Only 4 people voted....... Anyone else?

[Artax]

Hard to trust Birchall coming back from injury

[jamfrank]

how much cash do you have to spend on the ruck/def combo? I don't really like either of the options...

[Glort]

I don't like the options either  :P
But I only have 14k in the bank and Ibbo and Sandi to deal with...... . 'Sigh' im really stuck :(

[Shihan7]

Yeah, Sandi and Hanley imo.

[jamfrank]

I don't like the options either  :P
But I only have 14k in the bank and Ibbo and Sandi to deal with...... . 'Sigh' im really stuck :(

Do you have two or one trade? Sandi-->Z. Clarke, Ibbo-->Ellis (unless you already have him)

OR

Sandi-->Mumford and Ibbo-->Suban (who looked in devastating form on the weekend...but it was gws). Could also afford the cannon, rance or guerra?

Just some alternatives :)

[Glort]

Your a legend Jam!
Something to chew on with lunch :)