Time for Barlow

Started by Dasherman, July 30, 2013, 10:52:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Trade out which player

Josh P. Kennedy
17 (77.3%)
Jaeger O'Meara
5 (22.7%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Dasherman

Trading in Barlow but not sure who should go, it's out of JPK or JOM who are both ave 90. JPK has been disappointing this year but as normal trade him out and BANG scores high. The Suns do have any easier run home. Thoughts?

elephants

Suns run home is amazing. Ditch JPK I reckon man!

fertalong

JPK has too many contested handballs. No space to rack it up at all. Trade him out!

nrich102


m_zulian

Jpk is good at that other fantasy game. I would trade him over JOM

Ricochet

JPK's 2012 scores against his upcoming fixture:
Bullies: 114, 81
Collingwood: 153, 115
Saints: 99, 94
Geelong: 98, 76
Hawks: 149, 113, 96

I'd keep him, he loves the big games

thanme

JPK hasn't been anywhere near his 2012 form DT wise this year though.

I'd keep JOM. Is this for a bench spot though?

Ricochet

Yeh but at least he is proven. JOM is a kid. A gun. But still a kid

Adamant

I'd get rid of O'Meara personally.

JPK is having terrible season DT wise and O'Meara is having an amazing season... yet they still average the same. :P

So basically even at Kennedy's worst, he's still matching JOM...

Gotta back him in.

Ricochet

Quote from: Ricochet on July 31, 2013, 11:07:28 AM
JPK's 2012 scores against his upcoming fixture:
Bullies: 114, 81
Collingwood: 153, 115
Saints: 99, 94
Geelong: 98, 76
Hawks: 149, 113, 96

I'd keep him, he loves the big games
Also from Sydney's Bye in RD12 last year up until to RD19 JPK averaged only 88 per game. He currently averaging 87 for the same period.
He then went on to average 117 from RD19 up to and including the GF against Collingwood (x2), Bullies, Hawks (x2), Geelong and Adelaide. Almost the exact same final draw as last year. Think I've talked myself into bringing JPK in  :P

Dasherman

Good stats so may keep both at this stage as JOM has low BE this week. So Swallow is the other out and can afford J Selwood, Barlow or Griffin. Who do I get this week or do I cash up and get M Murphy for Swallow and get two of the Premo's next week for finals?
Current Mids Ablett, Swan, Pendle, S Mitchell, Cotchin, JPK, JOM, T Mitchell (Swallow, Gray DPP)