Super 10's v3...

[t-c 93]

Backs: Goddard, Duffield, Hodge, Kennelly, Ladson, Greenwood, Sheppard
Reserves: Maguire, Davis

Midfielders: Montagna, Selwood, Vince, Anthony, Trengove, Martin
Reserves: Banner, Kayler-Thompson

Ruck: Sandilands, Naitanui
Reserves: Warnock, Trengove

Forwards: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Franklin, Tippett, Hall, Ziebell, Walker
Reserves: Lobbe, Tapscott

[t-c 93]

The mids are not really stars but should hold up well enough during the season...

[hespey]

no

[t-c 93]

whats your advic then?

[hespey]

remove duffield, sheppard, anthony, naitanui, warnock, franklin, lobbe, tapscott and is that t.walker? if so, him too.

missing gilbee for duff, malceski has to be in there.

mcveigh for mid, anthony will give you nothing. im adverse to trengove, and there are much better rookie options than kt. barlow for one, he should actually be promoted.

nicnat.. no. has got lucky in a couple of games due to limited tog for cox and crap opposition. trade for him if he keeps it up in the first 2 weeks. seaby or ottens (pending injury) would be better choices. warnock wont play, and is too expensive for a non-player. downgrade to skipper or roughead.

franklin.. inconsistent, injuries, FA specialist and gets reported. hall is in the same boat, but 100k odd cheaper. and less opposition in forward line, with better delivery. go hall. you need rohan and rockliff in your forward line. tapscott is injured, lobbe wont play and if he does manage a game he is a showerkicker. t. walker? no. medhurst would be a better choice.


apart from that, you might be lacking a consistent captain. as it stands, riewoldt will be your captain, and he is pretty consistent. but maybe swap selwood for mitchell, and upgrade joey to swan or ablett if you have funds.


make these changes and your team will be 9-10/10

[hibbo]

Franklin is possibly the most under-valued player in the comp, should probably be a lock in most teams. Keep him! Don't mind the choice of Duffield, unique pick and there's no reason why he won't continue his good average.
Anthony is another real unique pick, based on his PS he looks the goods, Boomer should cop the #1 tag so he should be safe, risky pick but could pay off. However there's so much rookie value in the midfield you could drop him for a rookie (Barlow, Shuey etc.) and then upgrade Sheppard to maybe Hunt or Malceski.

Don't mind the pick of Nic Nat, but I think Hille offers better value. A pretty good forward line I think - Hall, Ziebell and Tippet should all continue to improve.
Overall a decent team.