Jack vs Danger

Started by quinny88, June 23, 2013, 11:21:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who for my last mid spot

Kieren Jack
6 (40%)
Patty Dangerfield
9 (60%)

Total Members Voted: 0

quinny88


Mat0369

I would say both again. Jack now, Danger later in a sideways trade for a premium who has been consistently under performing

quinny88

Quote from: Mat0369 on June 23, 2013, 11:23:11 PM
I would say both again. Jack now, Danger later in a sideways trade for a premium who has been consistently under performing

If I have a trade later in the season ill consider that but dont think i will lol

Mat0369

What is your midfield like?

!karis

I don't have either but they're both on my watchlist. They are a similar price and both performing well. If i was to split them I would say Danger. He has a better run through finals playing Dogs, Melb & Eagles. He will need to continue to perform if Adelaide are to have any hope of playing finals footy so they won't rest him either.

Can't go wrong either way IMO.

quinny88

Quote from: Mat0369 on June 23, 2013, 11:42:22 PM
What is your midfield like?

Gaj, Pendles, Watson, Swan, Cotchin, Kennedy, Priddis, Mundy (Mitchell, Hrovat)

Mundy is that one that I will upgrade to Jack or Danger

Mat0369

I just had a look at Dangers run vs Jacks, while Danger has GC this week (who are no longer a team you expect players to boom against anymore) and Jack has Carlton, Jack backs those up with Melbourne and GWS, Danger plays the Eagles and Pies. Dangerfield does have the easier finals fixture of the two.

Cotchin or Priddis would be the ones I would keep my eye on the next 3 weeks. Priddis is fairly consistent in his 95-110 scores week in week out. If Cotchin can't match Priddis, look at sideways trading him to Dangerfield.

Converted

Mundy to either of these two blokes at this stage of the season isn't a great idea quin! Really only gets you +10ppg, surely just save a trade or use is somewhere else or bring in Griffen who gives you +20ppg..

Also keep in mind Mundy has a good finals draw and Barlow could be missing in action for an extended period with his jaw, you saw what happened today when one of the big three were out of the freo midfield..

Obviously if Mundy is out next week then its a different story. Danger is your man. Think back to last year when Danger came home like a house on fire... Seems like his year is building again, and for that reason you will want him in your side at the end of the season when he puts that monster ceiling to full effect...

quinny88

Thanks for the feedback fellas

Bentekezzz

Flip a coin. I got Jack in this week and very happy about it, hes playing in a top team aswell. Gun. And a POD.

smashbox

Jack maybe more consistent slightly due to the fact hes got kennedy, hannebery etc in great form so less likely to get any tag from opposition.

whereas Dangers pretty much carrying the team, and also has a higher ceiling. But does get alot of attention which sometimes causes him to score poorly. Not often tho

Danger for me

Mat0369

The downside to Danger is that he might have a couple of games where they play him out of full forward for extended periods, because right now not only is he there best mid, but their best lead up forward.