ADCOCK OR DRUMMOND

[dreamteamking]

Highest Season Points Overall:

Adcock: 88.5
Drummond: 86.3

Last season Overall Points:

Adcock: 70.7
Drummond: 68.5

NAB Cup Scores this year... VS Essendon, VS St.Kilda:

Adcock: 69 and 51
Drummond: 113 and 60

Career Points:

Adcock: 71.3
Drummond: 70.3

Price:

Adcock: $313,800
Drummond: $304,100

WHO SHOULD I PICK UP

[nas]

Adcock

[valkorum]

Difficult choice.  Adcock has played more games per season than Drummond, thats about the only thing I can pick between the 2

[chunky]

I won't be picking either of these 2 guys but if I had to pick 1 it would be Adcock because he is more durable and will be getting more onball time than last year......although I don't see him racking up huge numbers when Black and Power are back in the team.

Re: Drummond. The fact that he has not been able to play more than 14 games in a season makes him a non-starter for me. I don't believe that his 'new running style' will solve his problems. He is a huge risk and will likely incur some sort of soft tissue injury during the year. It's a shame because he is such a great player when he actually plays.

Around that price, I think that McPhee is the best option. He is fit, has had a great pre-season and will be getting alot of cheap ball in the Bombers side this year. I think that he is a very good chance to return to his 2007 average which was 90.

Overall, I think there is much more choice this season in the sub 200k and over 350k brackets. IMO, the middle ground doesn't look that appealing to and nothing stands out to me other than McPhee.

[Mish]

Adcock!!!

i really like McPhee... put him in and out of the side constantly but i'm not so confident about him anymore as last year was a real poor one and i cant see him improving all that much as the youngsters at the bombers are getting older and better

[Ziebelling]

Tough choice. I cant see Adcock being a huge ballwinner like Drummond and see him avging higher than 85.

Drummond on the other hand is very unpredictable.

[love4thegame]

adcock is the better outta the two, but why get any when there are so many good cheap backs eg.
Houlihan 240k - back to full fitness
Raines 188k - back fit , ball magnet
Grimes 186k - in melbs best 22 now with 59 and 104 in nab
Geary - 190k , 88 and 82 in nab.

[Hawks_1976]

You would have to say Drummond, but will he play 22 games?
Both mid priced but can't see either of them improving their averages significantly enough to be classified as keepers.