Help please - who should stay who should go

[shanster]

Goodard B
Goodwin S
Enright C
Hunt J
Ladson R
Greenwood L
Maguire M
Trengrove J
Davis P

Ablett G
Montagna L
Deledio B
Armitage D
Trengrove J
Martin D
Melksham J
Bastinac R

Jolly D
Tippett K
Warnock R
Skipper W

Goodes A
O'Keefe R
Lockyer T
Franklin L
Hall B
Ziebell J
Lobbe M
Tapscott L
Podsiadly J

Iffy about Armitage... any better choices out there

[ossie85]

4th, 5th, 6th and 7th backmen are all risks, they all won't succeed.

Starting a rooky in 7th spot in the forward line...

Honestly think it needs a do-over, try cutting down on your $600k players

[shanster]

Some changes made... open for more suggestions

Goodard B
Goodwin S
Enright C
Hunt J
Ladson R replaced with Nicoski M
Greenwood L
Maguire M
Trengrove J
Davis P

Ablett G
Montagna L
Deledio B
Armitage D replaced with Dalziell B
Trengrove J
Martin D
Melksham J
Bastinac R

Jolly D
Tippett K
Warnock R
Skipper W

Goodes A
O'Keefe R
Lockyer T
Franklin L
Hall B
Ziebell J
Lobbe M replaced with Rohan G
Tapscott L
Podsiadly J

[nmarkou]

Goodes to old - Get Chapman
Podsiadly J to expensive - Get Perterson
Lockyer T - Get B Hall

[shanster]

Agree with the Chappo swap

Not sure Peterson would be in our (the hawks) best 22

I already have Hall

Thanks for the advice

[shanster]

pondering downgrading Nicoski to Malceski...

then upgrading Rohan to a non rookie...

who would be a good choice at around $200k

[Hippo]

Goodes to old - Get Chapman
Podsiadly J to expensive - Get Perterson
Lockyer T - Get B Hall

What am i missing here?...it doesn't get any cheaper than Pods

[shanster]

Which 2 of these would be the best bench midfielders

Melksham
Shuey
Bastinac
Banner
Scully
Morabito
Jetta

Is it worth keeping Goodes seeing he may play forward all year... or look elsewhere... who would be a good replacement... Chappo maybe?

[hespey]

Which 2 of these would be the best bench midfielders

Melksham
Shuey
Bastinac
Banner
Scully
Morabito
Jetta

Is it worth keeping Goodes seeing he may play forward all year... or look elsewhere... who would be a good replacement... Chappo maybe?

banner and jetta. closely followed by bastinac and shuey.

no to goodes.. pavlich would be best.

i liked armitage in there. curse those 3 games last year! he will score 90+ every week, so even at 400k is good value. hate dalziell, i would prefer mcveigh or masten.  :-*

[shanster]

thanks for that