Nic Nat, Stevie J or Watson?

Started by Vinny, May 19, 2013, 11:18:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Vinny

I can bring any of them in but which one?

Please comment your reason.


Thanks !

doogz

I have caff on the field so upgrading Neade to nic nat saves gives me + 50ppg.

For me to go to jobe it has to be from omeara who is avg around 90 to jobe 120 ppg, +30 ppg.  So getting nic nat is +20pgg for me.

Stevie J/Nic nat is a coin toss.  I chose nic nat because he was 10k cheaper, flipped 4 tails to 1 heads (actually did do a coin toss) and eagles have a pretty soft draw coming up to the bye.

TeeJay

would need to see your ruck, mid and fwd line but watson the best scorer

Vinny

Quote from: doogz on May 19, 2013, 11:23:48 PM
I have caff on the field so upgrading Neade to nic nat saves gives me + 50ppg.

For me to go to jobe it has to be from omeara who is avg around 90 to jobe 120 ppg, +30 ppg.  So getting nic nat is +20pgg for me.

Stevie J/Nic nat is a coin toss.  I chose nic nat because he was 10k cheaper, flipped 4 tails to 1 heads (actually did do a coin toss) and eagles have a pretty soft draw coming up to the bye.

I'm in pretty much the exact same situation as yours ! I will probably go Caff > Nic Nat and downgrade Neade > Staker. Probably get Jobe in after the byes. As for Stevie J, hopefully in the next two weeks I can make money for him.

Thanks man!

Vinny

Quote from: TeeJay on May 19, 2013, 11:24:23 PM
would need to see your ruck, mid and fwd line but watson the best scorer

My team isn't too great but here it is.

Ablett, JPK, Swan, Murphy, Cotchin, O'Meara, Whitfield, Evans

Cox, Gawn

Rocky, Kennedy, Zorko, Franklin, Neade, Caff

HotTiges

hope you didn't start Gawn this week.. if so, I'd be getting NicNat in for sure

Vinny

Quote from: HotTiges on May 19, 2013, 11:34:41 PM
hope you didn't start Gawn this week.. if so, I'd be getting NicNat in for sure

Unfortunately I did, alright thanks !

Dayze

Ur teams alrite bud. U probably don't want both caff and neade on field so for team balance probably nic nat.
But Watson is the best scorer of the lot and the best value.
Tbh they are all outstanding choices and u should b looking to get all of them in ASAP

doogz

Must get gawn off your starting line up.  I hope you have a DPP rook in your ruck.  Do the nic nat trade and slot him in the ruck. 

You have a pretty week fwd line as well, get in a cheapish fwd next week (gray or daisy if he plays).

Vinny

Quote from: Dayze on May 19, 2013, 11:35:51 PM
Ur teams alrite bud. U probably don't want both caff and neade on field so for team balance probably nic nat.
But Watson is the best scorer of the lot and the best value.
Tbh they are all outstanding choices and u should b looking to get all of them in ASAP

Thanks man ! I went Nic Nat as I need a better starter than Gawn. I could possibly get Stevie J next week and Watson further on !