Trading Brett Goodes

Started by Knowall, May 20, 2013, 12:00:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Knowall

With other rookies such as Vlastuin, O'meara and even Dwyer now playing well.  Do you think its time to trade Goodes.  Not sure on his BE but his last two scores are 67 and 77 so Id imagine his BE isnt too low.  Hes currently priced at 354k.

doogz

He's critical to my bye structure.  So keeping him at least till rd 13/14

HotTiges

unless your getting Hanley I would not be trading Goodes.. he is scoring better then pretty much all backline premos

TeeJay

b.e still only 69. hes a keeper anyway. bench cover at worst

Dayze

Agree with above. He is a really solid player.
Has a few clangers some games which hurt him but has a really neat left foot and plays the half back role really well.
Back rookies doing well but it won't happen every week. Mature body aswell which should last the year. Upgrade him last mate if u have to.

kilbluff1985

after round 11 bye will cost you bugger all to swap him with Birchall

hannebery2rohan

Will probably be the last backline player i trade out. Could end up keeping him for cover.

enzedder

Quote from: hannebery2rohan on May 20, 2013, 04:33:20 AM
Will probably be the last backline player i trade out. Could end up keeping him for cover.
I was thinking this but Terlich and Vlas have pushed him down the order at the moment.

hannebery2rohan

Quote from: enzedder on May 20, 2013, 05:25:38 AM
Quote from: hannebery2rohan on May 20, 2013, 04:33:20 AM
Will probably be the last backline player i trade out. Could end up keeping him for cover.
I was thinking this but Terlich and Vlas have pushed him down the order at the moment.

I wouldn't bank on Terlich keeping up his current rate of scoring. Melbourne have Freo, Hawks and Pies before their bye. Can see the option in trading Goodes, but given the inconsistency of a lot of premium backs, i'm happy to leave upgrading defenders until last. The 2 Terlich 100+ scores have been a blessing. Should now peak in price in 2-3 weeks, i just question his potential to score well in a team that will more than likely get thumped over the next 3 weeks.