Best 6 defenders of 2013

Started by monga77, May 15, 2013, 12:31:30 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who will be this years top 6 defenders? I'm going to assume Goddard, Hanley & birchall will be in there.

Gibbs
67 (1116.7%)
H Shaw
50 (833.3%)
Hibberd
28 (466.7%)
Hartlett
19 (316.7%)
H Taylor
4 (66.7%)
Duffield
11 (183.3%)
Heppell
18 (300%)
S.D Thompson
4 (66.7%)
Dixon
6 (100%)
Enright
1 (16.7%)
Reilly
3 (50%)
Malceski
1 (16.7%)
Waters
8 (133.3%)
Scotland
13 (216.7%)

Total Members Voted: 6

Voting closed: May 20, 2013, 12:31:30 AM

monga77

Would love to see everyone's opinion on who they think will be the top defenders for the year!
I am going to go out and say that Goddard, Hanley and birch will be in the top 6...
Comments welcome or if there is anyone I have missed (probably gone over the top with choices!)

tor01doc

Love seeing Hartlett get votes - not mine even though I have him!

Waters is certainly high risk / high reward.

Round 13 bye is a consideration with so many good defenders.

Nice poll.

tor01doc

For the record I went Gibbs, Shaw and Heppell.

doogz

Gibbs, shaw and scotland.... i really hope duffman makes it in there though!

tor01doc

So far 21/28 are round 13 and Goddard is a gimme.

Guns1989

I went waters, gibbs and shaw

tor01doc

So can prob assume

Goddard
Birchall
Hanley
Gibbs
Shaw

And the rest....

Oh and maybe Hibberd.

doogz

If you include total points, dont include shaw.  He is bound to miss another 1-2 weeks due to stupidity.

monga77

Very interesting, I thought Gibbs and shaw would be in there, even though I have a gut feeling Gibbs may not finish in the top 6...
I think Heppell, duff and hartlett will fill in the next couple of spots
Quote from: tor01doc on May 15, 2013, 01:14:07 AM

Waters is certainly high risk / high reward


Had waters last year, people say shaw is too risky but I find waters more frustrating