Good trade? Bad trade?

[craig22]

Ok guys thinking of doing this

Pittard ----> Terlich
Sam Jacobs----> shift Cox into Ruck and trade in Cloke

Or

Pittard---> shift Hartlett into defence and bring in Crouch
Sam Jacobs----> shift Cox into Ruck and trade in Cloke

Team as it stands now

DEF-- Goddard, Goodes, Yarran, Newman, Pittard, H. Shaw (Stevenson, Frost)
MID-- Pendlebury, Ablett, Wines, J. Kennedy, Priddis, Hartlett, Dangerfield, O'Meara (Viney, Kommer)
RUCKS-- Jacobs, Leuenburger (Blicavs, Naismith)
FWDS-- Martin, Kennedy, Cox, Rockliff, Franklin, Dwyer (Neade, Macaffer)

Will leave me $106,000 in kitty

[Ash A]

terlich will probably have better JS going forward but either trade would be a good trade id say.  ;)

[jamfrank]

It might be too early to trade out Jacobs...do you really need to get rid of him that badly?

[craig22]

It might be too early to trade out Jacobs...do you really need to get rid of him that badly?

Its more about getting Cloke in Jacobs is gonna drop price again Cloke will only go up with BE of 33 and Jacobs 109

[Ash A]

if kommer gets suspended then trade to crouch

[craig22]

if kommer gets suspended then trade to crouch

There was nothing in the hit by kommer soft if he does go

[jamfrank]

if kommer gets suspended then trade to crouch

There was nothing in the hit by kommer soft if he does go

Bradley did start bleeding from the head as a result of Kommer's hip making contact with it. I could see him getting one or two weeks for it.

[Windigo]

Hm, I'd go Cloke & Crouch.