Robbo for JJK? using the extra trades

[bradjones]

With Robbos B/E 184 and JJKs -37 is it worth bringing him in for Robbo? I'm not overly concerned with overall ranking more looking at leagues. With the Lions playing GC I reckon Karnezis will make his B/E of 64 so i'll keep him another week and upgrade him to the cheaper Robbo pocketing the extra cash, Good Call/Bad Call?

This week
Macaffer to Dwyer
Robbo to JJK

Next week
With the Lions next three games against the Suns, North and Melbourne i'll take it week by week with Karnezis
So either him or Patton to Robbo depending on B/Es

[Windigo]

What would it make your fwd line look like.... ???

[bradjones]

Rocky, Cox, Zorko, JJK, Patton, Karnezis, Neade, Dwyer

But I intended on bring back Robbo, the following week, it in essence is just Karnezis or Patton to JJK but over 2 weeks and using 2 trades instead of 1 which would pocket money extra money, I wouldn't consider doing something like that in previous seasons but with extra trades which are useless if not used it doesn't seem like a bad idea

Trading Robbo this week and bringing him back burns a trade, but pockets 50k - add that onto what ever Karny goes up in price

[The F.A.R.K.]

Rocky, Cox, Zorko, JJK, Patton, Karnezis, Neade, Dwyer

But I intended on bring back Robbo, the following week, it in essence is just Karnezis or Patton to JJK but over 2 weeks and using 2 trades instead of 1 which would pocket money extra money, I wouldn't consider doing something like that in previous seasons but with extra trades which are useless if not used it doesn't seem like a bad idea

Trading Robbo this week and bringing him back burns a trade, but pockets 50k - add that onto what ever Karny goes up in price

well at this stage karny wont be changing at all

[Sydney_Guy]

I traded Robbo for JJK last week, was a bit cautious of it initially. But looking back at it I don't regret it at all, plus it gave me a decent sum of cash in the bank :)

[bradjones]

B/E is only 65 against the Suns and if he dominates i'll just keep him and trade Patton, Robbo will lose 45-50K, if trade him out this week and bring him back in next for Patton i'll make 70-80k just there

[henry]

I'm in a very similar situation to you. Instead though I'm keeping Robbo and trading out Zorko, who I can see really struggling this year. Keeping karnezis, trading zorko for jjk. Robbo will average far higher than zorko I reckon and since I'm keeping him not concerned about his price drop.

[pommyadam]

as i posted elsewhere:

i'd hold off on Robbo for potentially 3 weeks yet, a projected fall of 50k this week
3 scores of 80 will bring him down to sub 400k
next 3 fixtures: Geelong [68 last year], West Coast [84 last year], and Adelaide [54 last year]

which primes him nicely for a immediate rise when the hapless Demons roll into town

i would trade, but personally i'm not even considering Robbo in the team till round 6

[bradjones]

as i posted elsewhere:

i'd hold off on Robbo for potentially 3 weeks yet, a projected fall of 50k this week
3 scores of 80 will bring him down to sub 400k
next 3 fixtures: Geelong [68 last year], West Coast [84 last year], and Adelaide [54 last year]

which primes him nicely for a immediate rise when the hapless Demons roll into town

i would trade, but personally i'm not even considering Robbo in the team till round 6

Good point

[bradjones]

Where are those experts?!

[Ricochet]

If your only going for League then definitely get rid of him. You need to make as much cash as possible and then start bringing in premiums for the second half of the seaosn