Karnezis = Pearce 2012?

[MiGZ]

With all this hype about trading out Karny...I can't help thinking about round 1 last year when I had Clancee in my team.

A shocking round 1 score from Clancee had me pushing the eject button on him faster than a one legged river dancer, and we all know how that ended up turning out by year's end. Clancee had a breakout and was more than servicable for the remainder of 2012 averaging in the mid 80's as a forward.

Now, Karny was the sub...and if this continues to happen then a trade is justified. But for me i'll be giving him one more week to prove his worth, I picked him for a reason and his NAB games warranted selection.

So maybe don't be so hasty is all i'm trying to say...we might have another Clancee situation on our hands here.

[glynman]

Problem for me (and probably lot's of other people) is that if I don't trade him out now, I won't be able to bring in JJK.

[HevvieEvvie]

I'm keeping him. worst case scenario is he get dropped this week and realizes he need to turn up next time!

Edit: actually worst case will be he scores 1 and get a LTI. I'm keep the faith  :-\

[Nails]

We have 44 trades, if he starts to show something just trade him in once he does.

[The F.A.R.K.]

Subs are being changed around weekly. Wouldn't expect him to cop a vest this week and against GC he could easily smash out a ton. Voss might be worried about playing him in the mid role but if lions start getting up against the suns Id expect Karnmy to be given a good crack in the mids

[me]

suppose it wouldn't be all that bad to keep him especially considering their upcoming games

i personally just can't stand the sight of him in my team tho =/ his 9 really aggrieved me, and im not feeling very forgiving

[HevvieEvvie]

Keep the faith! he is now becoming a POD

[dillez]

Trading him to Dwyer is really tempting I am seeing $$$$$ signs in front of my eyes... Maybe Mitchell out to Dwyer?

[Ricochet]

With 2 trades a week and the fact that his score of 9 will stay with him for 2 price changes I think we have to get rid of him and assess over the next two rounds