Field Karnezis/Caff/Neade/Dwyer

[Sweetness]

Hey guys,
Got a FWD line of: Zorko, Rocky, Robbo, Martin, Karny, Caff (Neade/Dwyer)

Who to put on the field?
Karny - Is there a chance of him getting a vest? (If I was 100% sure he would I would trade to JJK)
Dwyer- Named on field
Neade - Could score a few cheeky goals against GWS
Caff- A solid 60.

[Colliwobblers]

neade and karnezis for me. i cant get in jjk well i can but i think i will get burger instead.

jjk for karnezis i take it you would have to do and i am not sure i would do that....  karnezis may be sub beams is better but i still think karnezis has earned a spot in the side and should play most games and full games if he stays in preseason form.

hard to guage on last weeks team effort but it would be rough if he was made sub.

still beams was great when he came on, this too might make him the vestee again...

[Football Factory]

Karny will play better this week .. Im going with Neade at the moment over Caff  :o  just because of Caff being on an extended bench.

[Matt_352]

Got karny and byrnes on field with caff and neade on the pine :)

[fertalong]

Karny and JJK if you can do it. If not then Karny and Caff is the go

[powersuperkents]

Karny and Neade, they are the only two named in on field positions so far so less green vest risk

[LF]

Karnezis is named on the bench

[glynman]

Gotta go with Caff over Neade, just a more reliable option you'd think, because of his experience. Karney is a dodgey one but kinda needs to be on the field to justify his cost.

[powersuperkents]

Karnezis is named on the bench

Really shower, He shouldn't be green vested though, he was given the green light but I can't see the Lions green vesting him

[powersuperkents]

Gotta go with Caff over Neade, just a more reliable option you'd think, because of his experience. Karney is a dodgey one but kinda needs to be on the field to justify his cost.

I'm going Neade over Caff. Neade in guaranteed forward pocket, Caff has a strong chance at being sub

[glynman]

Gotta go with Caff over Neade, just a more reliable option you'd think, because of his experience. Karney is a dodgey one but kinda needs to be on the field to justify his cost.

I'm going Neade over Caff. Neade in guaranteed forward pocket, Caff has a strong chance at being sub

Is Neade a chance of a red vest though? Can see him being subbed off if he plays tentatively like last week and if Port are smashing them

[powersuperkents]

Gotta go with Caff over Neade, just a more reliable option you'd think, because of his experience. Karney is a dodgey one but kinda needs to be on the field to justify his cost.

I'm going Neade over Caff. Neade in guaranteed forward pocket, Caff has a strong chance at being sub

Is Neade a chance of a red vest though? Can see him being subbed off if he plays tentatively like last week and if Port are smashing them

That is a really really really good point man, I didn't think of that. Looking at their team I can't see any other more likely candidates for the red vest  :-\

Would Caf in the green vest (on in 3rd-4th quarter) against Carlton score more than Neade in the red vest (off in 3rd-4th quarter) against GWS?

[glynman]

Nah, I think if Caff gets green and Neade gets red, Neade will score the most. It all depends on whether they get the vest though lol...I wish Collingwood played Friday night.

[powersuperkents]

Nah, I think if Caff gets green and Neade gets red, Neade will score the most. It all depends on whether they get the vest though lol...I wish Collingwood played Friday night.

Same here. I hate going into the round with potential vests. So lucky Mitchell was on my bench last week instead of Viney like I was going to originally do  ;D

[Ricochet]

Karny is easily the best of the 4, he needs to be on your field.
For the last spot I'm leaning towards Dwyer because he is named on the field (yes i know players named on the field can still get the vest) and because I thought he should enough intensity and work rate to be given the chance of a full game.