Main Menu

Breakout M5

Started by WillDel, March 27, 2013, 04:24:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

WillDel

Can't split the 2 -

D Rich - 78-85-90 over the last 3 years
+
Rich has had the far better preseason
Highest chance of breaking out
Designated kicker
Brisbane on the move

-
Has shown he will get the #1 tag
Part of a team that will probably be in the bottom 8
Everyone not on Mundy will have Rich

D Hannebery - Mid 80s the last 3 years
+
May not get the #1 tag
Part of a team in the top 8
Accumulates the ball
POD

-
Shorter preseason
Shoulders
Does he have the consistency to breakout?

Anyone have any thoughts on the two. Im at a point of flipping a coin. Hanners will be a POD but Rich is more likely to breakout

Baggers2012

This is my last dilemma as well mate! Toying with the idea of Lucas at M5 and upgrading pettard to Bartel. I really don't know, the tag scares me away from rich, whereas hanners won't cop the tag. Though I do think Rich is the better player, I would go hanners. GWS & Gold Coast in the first two rounds helps hanners case.

Baggers2012

I put it to a vote last night. I think it ended:
Hanneberry: 6
Rich: 6
Steven: 4

It's a flip of the coin mate

Colty

IM jumping on Mitch Wallis, the boy posted heaps of scores between 80-90 I think he is a huge chance of averaging over 100. JUMP ON!!

WillDel

Cheers all round. I agree, will flip. I head Zorko outlining that Rich has been helping him with ways to shake a tag. Though I have yet to see Rich really shake one in the same way that Gaz, Kennedy, Swan and Pendles can. Hanners is down the pecking order of requiring a tag. Plus the kid just runs. Will run all day inside or out. Plus the easier draw makes it a bit easier to justify DH.

Lucas I would worry about. Admittedly first round draft pick with a coach who has proven to be able to draw out the very best ala D Thomas. Still not convinced he has that competitive streak that lifts them to an elite.

Gavward