Pretty solid IMO, Need your unbiased opinions! ?/10 please

[tferrier18]

Goddard, Enright, Hodge, McDonald, Kennelly, Ladson, Greenwood (Silvagni, trengrove)

Ablett, Mitchell, Vince, Masten, Martin, Barlow (shuey, Banner)

Sandilands, Kreuzer (Skipper, McNamara)

Riewoldt, Pavlich, Lockyer, Giansiracusa, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Walker (Hitchcock, Podsiadly)

3.5k in the bank :(

I'm anticipating negative feedback from lockyer, but I'm not keen on anyone below his price as a prem. Harvey will get tagged week in week out, sylvias a dud, franklin is a maybe, gray can't go in my team before I see him play before r 1, porps injured, lecras is a no go.

If you could please give me a rating out of 10 and some feedback that'd be great. I've given a lot of comments to people's teams so I'd be very appreciative if I got some responses :) thanks in advance!

[Fenno]

not bad at all. mcnamara won't play all year thats about all. differant to my team but this team has promise

[tferrier18]

cheers man, yeah macnamara is just there to free up some cash...I figured I'd hardly ever need to use two emergency rucks.

[stevesowde]

Nice team mate.
You don't think Vince will cop the #1 tag week in week out?
I like McDonald as an original, but is he going to get you the growth you're chasing?
Starting Barlow also might be a problem if he doesn't make the run on side in Rd1. You could cop a donut or wo there.
Good luck!

[whatahugescore]

Team is looking in tip-top shape mate. The only question id have is barlow. If shuey or banner dont play ull cop a doughnut, as barlow is stiull on the rookie list and hasnt been promoted to the senior list. Not sure about the rold lockyer will play this year...but your reasoning behing picking him is a good one. 8.5/10

[Disco]

Your'e on field team is solid. 8.5/10. Just watch the NAB and R1 for your bench players as I don't have real confidence that any of them will start especially Banner, mcnamara, hitchcock and podsiadly. I believe Silvagni and Barlow are yet to be brought off the rookie list but after last weeks performance they both will be.

[ando_10]

barlow on the rookie list? dont think so disco he was taken in the draft so he can play staight up

[BGK]

Michael Barlow is indeed on the rookie list. But it is almost guaranteed that he will be promoted.

[Wild Thing]

I think your forward line is a little thin.  Giansiracusa is a very frustrating SC player.  Sure, his average might be mid 90's, but that doesn't mean he scores mid 90's every week.  The deviation between his scores is huge (from 55-60 to 135-140).  Is this really the kind of player you want to have in your side??  I'm a Dogs supporter and I wouldn't even consider him.  There are a couple of moves to possibly consider:
Downgrade one of Ladson, Kenelly or Greenwood to Maguire (if he's going to play of course) in which you could pick up $132k for Ladson, $206k for Kennelly or $122k for Greenwood.  I'd use that money to upgrade Giansiracusa to almost anyone you want.  The other thing you could do with the money is upgrade Lockyer and replace Giansiracusa with someone like Josh Kennedy (WC) who I think has a far bigger upside than Giansiracusa.

[tferrier18]

thanks for the comments guys,

my choice of barlow is based on his avg of 30 disposals in vfl and then grabbing 29 against melb...definitely gets a lot of it and uses it fairly well for his experience...will watch him and his role in the team in leading weeks to see if his spot is justified in my team...wouldn't mind fitting trengove back in, but definitely need the cash to balance out my team...

Will definitely be watching the players on my bench and how they fit into their respective teams, if it doesnt look like they'll get regular gametime then they'll be out...Are there any other comments about potential changes to my team - other than changes to the bench/rookies? thanks for the perspective on giansiracusa mate, will definitely be taken into consideration.

[Crushemall]

I like the team I'm giving u an 8/10 my main prob is the irishman, then the VFL rookie listee who is a maybe and I heard Mundy wrapping him up so could be a smokey watch that space Lockyer at his best could have good upside but I feel he's too risky at this price although I've gone with Big Bad Bustling Barry so who am i to talk hey like your side

[Crushemall]

By the way the Lions are winning the comp this year surely you can find room for Rich, Brown, Adcock, Charman etc.???