Bartel vs Pavlich vs Robinson

[lollipop man]

Which one?

[Windigo]

I'd go Robbo or Bartel. Pav would be my third pick TBH.

[xumtinglong]

Robbo - he's not going to a tag

Bartel - will have a forward tag

Pav - will always cop their best tag

[Windigo]

Robbo - he's not going to a tag

Bartel - will have a forward tag

Pav - will always cop their best tag

I wouldn't be so confident on that...

[Artax]

If Robbo stinks it up he will become SJ all over the place in a week or 2

[essendon2]

I've gone Chappy over Robbo, just hate inconsistency from players :P

p.s I voted Bartel (I've got Chappy and Bartel) 8)

[Adamant]

I've gone Chappy over Robbo, just hate inconsistency from players :P

p.s I voted Bartel (I've got Chappy and Bartel) 8)

Why does everyone think Robbo is so inconsistent? He scored 82+ in all but four games... if anything, he's got great consistency.

[essendon2]

I've gone Chappy over Robbo, just hate inconsistency from players :P

p.s I voted Bartel (I've got Chappy and Bartel) 8)

Why does everyone think Robbo is so inconsistent? He scored 82+ in all but four games... if anything, he's got great consistency.

82+ isn't exactly what I want when I'm paying 480k... Bartel scored over 100, 60% of the time 8)

[Windigo]

I've got Bartel & Robbo BTW.  ;)

[Yoshi]

They will all be good options but I'm on the Robbo bus as my preference.

Currently I have Robbo, Bartel, Zorko & Rocky.

[essendon2]

They will all be good options but I'm on the Robbo bus as my preference.

Currently I have Robbo, Bartel, Zorko & Rocky.

replace Robbo with Chapman, and that's my FWD line 8)

[Adamant]

I've got Robbo & Bartel as well.

Cox, Bartel, Rockliff, Robinson and N.Riewoldt as my 5 premo forwards. I'm planning on going NRoo to Pav after round 4 when Pav is hopefully back to full fitness.

I don't like starting Pav anymore as he's had no pre-season and will probably get toweled up by Glass round 1. Hopefully I'm wrong though.

[pinochio]

heya adament,

just wondering where you got a spare 100k for rooey as M5?
....been trying but can only get like 350k for M5??

also out of robbo and bartel, who you like? (would love dusty to become robbo but dont i just cant find cash anywhere lolz)

[Adamant]

Could you post your team here? would be easier to tell you where I've found the spare cash for NRoo. :)

Robbo vs Bartel... Robbo easily. I'm a massive Robbo fan and after watching him pump out that 141 against Port back in 2011, I had him on the radar for a mid spot in 2012. :o

He then got DPP eligibility for 2012 and was an absolute lock for me. I was confused as to why he was only in about 4% of teams. He was easily on track for a 100+ average last year before tagging roles and an eye injury really hampered his scoring and dragged his average down to 92.

With Malthouse as coach, I am confident that Robbo will get out of these little tagging roles and break the 100 mark. I could guarantee 95+ at the least.

As I said though, I've got both locked and loaded for 2013. 8)

[KoopKicka]

Am I the only one not running with any of those 3?

Cox, Rockliff, Zorko and Martin for me.