lucas+whitfield or maloney+lonergan?

[masher]

For mid5 and 6 which is the better choice?

[turry17]

Lonergan is injured so wouldn't go him

[masher]

That's right! I forgot that he was

Would you go lucas ahead of Maloney?

I think he could be a better scorer but JS?

[GoLions]

I think Moloney will be a better scorer. Is there anyone you could get instead of Lonergan? Wines, O'Meara, Crouch, Mitchell, Viney. There must be at least one that you don't have.

[masher]

Wines is the only one that I don't have.

I might be able to do a Maloney Wines if I make up some cash from elsewhere

[Ricochet]

yeh i would look at Moloney + Wines combo

[masher]

I've updated the poll from lonergan to wines.

Thanks for such quick replies ive been racking my brain on this

[Holz]

Wines is the only one that I don't have.

I might be able to do a Maloney Wines if I make up some cash from elsewhere

maloney better than lucas: Maloney flat out is just the better player, lucas wont be as good when carlton are full strength and playing real games.

wines better than whitfield: think he will score more at a cheaper price.

[Jukes]

Lucas 80, Whitfield 77
vs
Maloney 85, Wines 80

(b) wins easily.