Rolling the dice

Started by mabo, March 18, 2013, 08:28:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mabo

Its a game of risks after all.



ubeaut

I like what your doing but there's a few too many risks! Most of all - - -  the mids have to be stronger to be competitive. That's where the most points are scored. It's no good having a strong backline when most score under 100 (Newman,Hartlett).

Also with the money u saved in the mids I thought the fwds would be stronger. Karnezis,Monfries,Watts ? What about Cox,Bartel,Walker,Buddy,Pavlich,Chappy,Stevie J ?

I would get rid of Hartlett and Newman at least for rookies. Get rid of Heppell (at least out of the mids) Then get some good players in the mids and fwds. They don't have to be the same as everyone elses. What about Priddis,Griffen,Watson,Pavlich,Chappy,Sloane,Jack etc. ? Hill could be replaced by Viney for 40 K +. Have a look at Varcoe for a cheap fwd option if u need 1.

yangers95

i admire ur gusto mate, but i have to say that mid may get blown away!

Reckon two of ur backs have to go, purely for balence's sake, plus

i reckon Heppell should only be chosen up back, not too inspiring seeing him as M2, reccommend u get AT LEAST 2, preferably 3 premo mids, most others should be rolling around with at least 4.

just a hypothetical mate, pendlebury, kennedy and danger vs hep, moloney and lucas? i know mid rooks this year are pretty strong and ur premo backs would outscore back rooks but still...

good choice with ur rucks but coxy should be a must in the fwds!!!

zorko is a gun but for some reason i reckon hes overpriced...just wait till he rips out tons every week i guess haha.
matty wright a unique pick, but only heard good things bout him
not sold on gus.

overall reckon u should work on more balence, i can see the tactic in stacking ur fwds nd backs at the expense of ur mid cause of the rooks but i reckon ubeaut is spot on, ur fwds look a tad weak considering the strength of ur mids. good luck though!

BB67th

Well as you say it's a risk! It's something different and while I would never do it with my team, it could work for you. If anything I would be going the opposite, stacking the mids and going short in other places, but good luck to you! Keep us posted on how this structrue goes mate ;)