Toby Greene (solid preseason scores) v. Marc Murphy

Started by luke.clancy4, March 18, 2013, 12:58:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to fill M4 spot ? Mid stands as Swan, Ablett, Pendles, Greene/Murphy/??, Fyfe, Wines, Mitchell, O'Meara

Toby Greene
8 (36.4%)
Marc Murphy
6 (27.3%)
Jack Redden
4 (18.2%)
A Swallow
4 (18.2%)
Other
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

luke.clancy4

Toby Greene's pre season..
round 1 short format..66 v. Sydney and a 29 v Carl
followed by 83 v. Brisbane when he came on as a sub in Q2
followed by 77 v. Ess , with limited game time and Hocking tag
121 in the latest prac match

Murphy been unsettling to say the least..

Jukes

If money isn't an option, go with Swallow.

Don't go with Murphy, his nab cup has been shower.

Dangerfield been considered? I've got him, he's performed very well this nab cup.

luke.clancy4

Yeah certainly considering Danger, but just dont like him copping all the tags, especially Hocking round 1

Ziplock

According to the FB toby greene appreciation page, there's been some friction between greene and leon cameron, to the point where he may be requesting a trade at the end of the season :(

could it affect him?

luke.clancy4

Quote from: Ziplock on March 18, 2013, 01:17:45 PM
According to the FB toby greene appreciation page, there's been some friction between greene and leon cameron, to the point where he may be requesting a trade at the end of the season :(

could it affect him?

Hasnt have seemed to affect his scoring of late, but valid point

tbagrocks

Teams will quickly learn if they haven't already that you can't tag Dangerfield, which is why they went to Sloane often last year

essendon2

Quote from: tbagrocks on March 18, 2013, 01:46:46 PM
Teams will quickly learn if they haven't already that you can't tag Dangerfield, which is why they went to Sloane often last year
last year, Dangerfield was in hot form and we still decided to put Hocking to Thompson. I'd be surprised if Hocking went to Danger, but regardless, Hocking isn't an amazing tagger. Danger should go 100+

I like JPK atm, especially with his start  8)

Andrew

#7
Quote from: Ziplock on March 18, 2013, 01:17:45 PM
According to the FB toby greene appreciation page, there's been some friction between greene and leon cameron, to the point where he may be requesting a trade at the end of the season :(

could it affect him?


If it's real? Do they give a reason for the friction?

And which page are you referring to - not this one which has 3 likes I hope: https://www.facebook.com/TobyGreeneAppreciationSociety

I can't find a FB page about Toby Greene making this claim anywhere.

luke.clancy4

Bit off topic, but just quickly, thoughts on Deledio v. Watson v. Cotchin?

charliesheen


POK252

Quote from: Andrew on March 18, 2013, 03:11:53 PM
Quote from: Ziplock on March 18, 2013, 01:17:45 PM
According to the FB toby greene appreciation page, there's been some friction between greene and leon cameron, to the point where he may be requesting a trade at the end of the season :(

could it affect him?


If it's real? Do they give a reason for the friction?

And which page are you referring to - not this one which has 3 likes I hope: https://www.facebook.com/TobyGreeneAppreciationSociety

I can't find a FB page about Toby Greene making this claim anywhere.

My 2nd favourite player outside the mighty Pies!! Would love to see him in the Black & White. Early days but can always dream  ;D