Final draft before teams, please help.

[bmac25]

Pretty settled on my lineup now, just waiting for team announcements.  What do you think? Any feedback would be much appreciated.

D: Goddard, Gibbs, Duffield, Watts, Vlastuin, Goodes (Stevenson, Terlich)

M: GAJ, Swan, JPK, Fyfe, Rich, Lucas, Mitchell, O'Meara (Viney, Crouch)

R: Cox, Blicavs (Currie, Rowe)

F: Buddy, Bartel, Rockliff, Martin, Kennedy, Macaffer (Kerridge, Lee)

Leftover Cash: $10k

[cortez]

Defense is strong, don't mind the Watts pick just not sure how he will go if he starts to get a tag.

Mids are good, 3 prems and 3 mid pricers, hope it pays off for you. not sure on Lucas though but if he kills ityour laughing!

Rucks i dont like im sorry to say. What happens if your 3 rookies dont play or score really low. You cant exactly swap Rowe to your forwards for a ruckman cause you have no ruckman in your forward line. I wiuld look very closely at this line.

Forwards ar decent. I like Bartel as ihavent seen him in many teams around here and he is over his injuries and is a star. but i'd be trying to put a ruckman in here somewhere.

After that 7.5/10

Gotta fix up those rucks!!!

[GCSkiwi]

Defence similar to mine, don't think Vlastuin is worth the 30k extra over the likes of Pittard but see who's named. Defence is the line I think you can afford to go cheap on, would rather see a rookie D4 than R2 (see later comment).

Mids: Interesting choice with Fyfe, Rich and Lucas. Do you think they'll all either make good cash or turn into a keeper? I don't think Rich will be top 10 by the end and I don't see the upside of Lucas over a rookie.

Rucks: I don't think Blicavs has anywhere near the life needed for R2. Cats have West, H-Mac and Vardy to take his spot, and I reckon that will only be about 3/4 weeks at most.

Forwards: Nice, some questions over JS or the rookies (Kerridge and Lee) but what else is new. Martin is a "never again" for me but can see why he's popular.

Rucks are a big downside for me, I don't give ratings because they're so arbitrary and meaningless but I think this still needs a little work ;)

[bmac25]

Moved Rowe to forward to allow for cover.  Kerridge out.  Witts as R4.  Between the 4 rookie rucks, I should get 1 decent solid performer.  The rest will make me some amount of cash.  Not fussed if I have to trade one early (r4-5 or so).  It's risky having 4 rookie rucks, but this year it looks like they might get some game time early on.  Will have to wait and see on the teams.