too many smokies?

[starz]

goddard gibbs heppel pittard goodes terlich
vlaustin stevenson

gaz swan pendles scooter selwood mundy steven wines omera
jones crouch

cox kreuzer
currie daw

rockliff wright martin bewick karnesiz mcaffer
rowe dwyer

all depends on round one teams obviously. dont have kane mitchell as i see him being used as a defensive forward. steven i like him being in his fifth year with increased midfield time and a mad preseason only thing he doesn't tick for me is that he plays for the saints who i dont see having the greatest of all years. Mundy i see as this years jobe watson. bewick is a bit of an inspired pick purely due to the fact that i dont like ny of the other mid priced fwds and i think he has the potential to average 80 which i would take. Also the lions are up and about which will be good for him.
Anyway what are your thoughts??

[stew42]

Backs: Good structure, good premos, good rooks. However, I'd put Vlastuin on the field Rnd 1 (if named, of course). Bit cookie cutter, but good 9/10

Mids: Swan, Gaj, Pendles. Strong (but Jukes will probably disagree) If Scooter is freed from his tagging role, I can see him going 108. But that's a big if. I'd go someone else (Jack? Ebert?) and sideways before his first price rise if this is the case. Mundy had a few injury worries in the pre season, haven't heard much since then, so should be good. Steven is a great choice for potential breakout. Perhaps consider Armitage? Great rookies. 8.5/10

Rucks: Cox is a solid choice. Kreuz is a risky one. He has the talent in spades, but injury has him not fulfilling his potential. Under Malthouse I expect (read: hope to hell!!!) him to improve, perhaps to a high 80s average. I can't really comment on your rooks. Just consider anyone who's playing Rnd 1. 8/10

Fwds: Rocky, tick. Wright has risk, he a bit of an unknown, but odds are on him maintaining his average. It all depends on whether he can take any midfield time. Martin is a good choice, although I'm always apprehensive about him. Bewick is an alright choice, but there are better. I wouldn't select someone based on NAB performances alone. That being said, I do have Karnzy in my team  ::) Macaffer is the best of a bad lot. I'd be worried about the JS of your bench. Perhaps bring in someone like Neade? 7.5/10

Overall: This is a good team! The only smokey in your team I'd reconsider is Bewick 8.25/10

[j]

Instead of Berwick and karnezis why not consider Lewis Jetta and Jake Stringer. I've been hearing nothing but good things bout stringer and h will get solid game time and the swans have a dream draw to start the season jet tags numbers should skyrocket early on