which premo ?? Watson v Cotchin v Murph

Started by bundyboy, March 17, 2013, 11:12:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Excluding GAJ, Swann and Pendles - then which ONE of these three to start???

Watson
10 (43.5%)
Cotchin
9 (39.1%)
Murphy
4 (17.4%)

Total Members Voted: 3

Voting closed: March 20, 2013, 11:12:03 PM

bundyboy

well can't afford every premo to start, so if we exclude GAJ, Swann and Pendles then who is going to sit as 4th premo to start??

Boyd - just out of price range, so one of these othres is the choice..
'
Murphy seems so cheap...
Cotchin - i'm liking him more for SC than DT - but maybe just a gone both ways?
Watson - hate essendon, but he is a gun..

i've had all 3 in and out - amd just can't seem to make up my mind...

thoughts ??


Jukes

Swallow, Stanton and Dangerfield > them three for value and scoring potential.

Get Spudlett out and go with two of the above. Will leave you with a fair amount of cash to fix other spots.

woodsy175

Spudlett... wowee watched footy before mate?

bundyboy

hey thanks,

Got Danger,, GAJ is a question - super expensive, so not sold yet, but still in at the moment

Ypu really think swallow will avg as much as either of the others ??  - love him as a player, but not top tier DT IMO

Stanton?? too hard on my blood pressure - yes has high potential scores, but seems to have been locked down plenty of times too, whilst Watson far more consistent if i wanted a Bomber midfielder...

still tossin it all in the air - so really happy to get some independent opinions !! tks


Jukes

#4
My predictions
Swallow: 111
Danger: 109
Stants: 113

Cotch: 111
Watto: 111
Murphy: 103

Ablett: 114

tbagrocks

Dangerfield's going to new levels so nice pick ;)  the others, Watson first, all are price drop candidates

Justin Bieber

Seriously Swallow 111? He struggles to carry the team sometimes.

RookieDTer

Who had the better pre-season, Deledio or Cotchin?
http://freako.championdata.com/2013/Fantasy_Freako_Pre_2.pdf

Who is cheaper, Deledio or Cotchin?

Simple choice is simple?

essendon2

Quote from: whatlez on March 18, 2013, 02:51:06 AM
Seriously Swallow 111? He struggles to carry the team sometimes.
With the impovement of his teammates, he should be able to free up a bit more and get handball receives instead of always dishing it out .
I don't think 110 is unreasonable

Windigo

I'd go with Jobe, will be solid as always and a good honest scorer for any team. Unique as well I reckon... ???