Can You Hack It? **POLL INCLUDED**

Started by Madsnake, March 19, 2013, 10:25:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What would you rate it in the long run?

1
1 (6.3%)
2
0 (0%)
3
1 (6.3%)
4
2 (12.5%)
5
4 (25%)
6
3 (18.8%)
7
3 (18.8%)
8
1 (6.3%)
9
1 (6.3%)
10
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Madsnake



Thought i'd mix it up a bit this year with the added amount of trades and go a little more unique than usual and a little more mid-priced, any views or ideas are welcome and appreciated, but to be honest i'm very happy with it.

Jukes


Madsnake


j

Backs 5/10. Weak links are Armstrong and tambling and to a lesser extent Heppell. I'd downgrade tambling to upgrade Armstrong.
Mids7/10 weak links montagna and McVeigh
Rucks8.5/10 your picks are ok but I think your have spent too much here, you cann afford to downgrade maric and use that money to upgrade someone else.
Forwards5/10 weak links are Bartell and rioli. Both are getting old and inconsistent there are much better options for that money.
Over all maybe 6.5/10 it's not the worst team I've seen but if your going to use this many midpricers (a few to many IMO) then they need to be much better picks than the ones you've gone for here.

Mr.Craig


Madsnake

#5
Quote from: j on March 19, 2013, 11:52:12 PM
Backs 5/10. Weak links are Armstrong and tambling and to a lesser extent Heppell. I'd downgrade tambling to upgrade Armstrong.
Mids7/10 weak links montagna and McVeigh
Rucks8.5/10 your picks are ok but I think your have spent too much here, you cann afford to downgrade maric and use that money to upgrade someone else.
Forwards5/10 weak links are Bartell and rioli. Both are getting old and inconsistent there are much better options for that money.
Over all maybe 6.5/10 it's not the worst team I've seen but if your going to use this many midpricers (a few to many IMO) then they need to be much better picks than the ones you've gone for here.

Thanks for the constructive critiscm man, i'm not sure if i agree but i'll take that into consideration. I have put alot of research into each of my picks aswell as my Mid-pricers and i don't normally go down the mid priced path but with the showery flowered up new amount of trades i thought why not.

Quote from: Mr.Craig on March 20, 2013, 02:23:51 AM
Montagna is suspended.

really, how long for?

Chopps

First thing is don't listen to jukes re "spudlett" ablett is all class, even if he drops in scoring you know what your getting.

Backs are good and Heppel is a good pick not weak at all for  a back, perfect third year break out candidate and if he doesn't break out still got a guy who ll go 90 at least.

Only worries for Armstrong and tambling is then getting a regular gig, tambling has to perform this year and as I understand Armstrong would be vying for a spot in a tough team to stay in.

Mids I think joey is out for 1 and can't really see him boosting his average .think you could do better then mcveigh someone like fyfe, goodes should be down back, dpp isn't so important early, I don't know enough on towers to give any decent advice

Rucks, how many games will blicavs play you'd think once one of the other rucks are right he ll be out, don't know their injury status
Why not drop Maric and play cox there?

Forwards, bartel should do well and you know what you ll get. Rioli is an interesting pick, I think you could do better with someone like Martin

Otherwise team is good only thing to remember with all these trades if going for overall others will be trying to generate money and you may be forced to do some fixing up.

Madsnake

#7
Quote from: Chopps on March 20, 2013, 01:23:00 PM
First thing is don't listen to jukes re "spudlett" ablett is all class, even if he drops in scoring you know what your getting.

Backs are good and Heppel is a good pick not weak at all for  a back, perfect third year break out candidate and if he doesn't break out still got a guy who ll go 90 at least.

Only worries for Armstrong and tambling is then getting a regular gig, tambling has to perform this year and as I understand Armstrong would be vying for a spot in a tough team to stay in.

Mids I think joey is out for 1 and can't really see him boosting his average .think you could do better then mcveigh someone like fyfe, goodes should be down back, dpp isn't so important early, I don't know enough on towers to give any decent advice

Rucks, how many games will blicavs play you'd think once one of the other rucks are right he ll be out, don't know their injury status
Why not drop Maric and play cox there?

Forwards, bartel should do well and you know what you ll get. Rioli is an interesting pick, I think you could do better with someone like Martin

Otherwise team is good only thing to remember with all these trades if going for overall others will be trying to generate money and you may be forced to do some fixing up.


Chopps, you just showed j how to give proper constructive critiscm, you're a champ and you do make some pretty good points there.

Windigo

Yeah, Hackers that'd be Chopps not Jukes.  :P

Mr.Craig