Which D3?

[Degsman]

This time I am looking at who should fill the spot of D3

Defence looks like this:

Goddard, Gibbs, ......., Vlastuin, Goodes, Terlich, (Docherty, Stevenson)

Looking for league win, not overall :)


Who should get the spot?

[GoLions]

Well I originally had Birchall. Then he became Hartlett. Then Duffman. And now Hanley.
Should probably go with Heppell  ;D

[Degsman]

My problem exactly lions :P

[jimmytigs]

hartlett & heppell 3 & 4 not looking at the rest,if i was to go for another pricier back at 5 it would be broughton or lake who come a bit cheaper,not looking at other 3 at all

[tor01doc]

Why on Earth would anyone select Heppell when Goddard and Gibbs (and maybe Shaw) are locks.

A guaranteed loss of points for no guarantee of extra points.

Unless of course you aren't getting Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Watson, Beams or Dangerfield.

[Degsman]

well i already have goddard and gibbs and i can't afford shaw so we are looking at other options :)

With heppell playing more in the midfield he is a viable option :)

[GoLions]

Why on Earth would anyone select Heppell when Goddard and Gibbs (and maybe Shaw) are locks.

A guaranteed loss of points for no guarantee of extra points.

Unless of course you aren't getting Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Watson, Beams or Dangerfield.

Or unless you plan on tanking in R13   ;D

Is a good point though, if you have more than 2 of those midfielders you just mentioned, Heppell probably isn't the best option.

[tbagrocks]

Hartlett is a star

[Degsman]

Hartlett it is i guess :)