Dwyer vs Neade

[GCSkiwi]

Seems like a no brainier to me but is my final decision for F8. My concern is all my port rookies, I have Pittard, Stevenson, Heath, Wines, and Mitchell. Neade would make 6. But I think Dwyer will be out in a couple of weeks with Daisy due back...
Thoughts?

[Jmachete]

Neade would seem less risky JS wise and scored higher in the Nab Cup, although costs more and we have a lot port players

Dwyer is cheap, and a mature age but has risky JS

[Jmachete]

Dwyer as sub only playd the last qtr and score 49 points!

Pretty decent

[johnnytheboy1]

I would have to say Neade as there are plenty of Magpie stars to come back into that lineup.Hitchcock is the only threat to neade's position.

[quinny88]

Dwyer as sub only playd the last qtr and score 49 points!

Pretty decent

Didn't he play all of the 3rd and 4th?

[Colliwobblers]

main concern with dwyer is job security, i will be wrapped if i get 3 games out of him or more and any price rise at all, also have neade.

thomas and krak and fas to come back in and maybe didak - zero future in owning dwyer just hope as i said i get a rise or two out of him before another rook sticks his head up to replace him in my team.

tho i think i'll be sitting on him for awhile waiting for a fwd rook to take as a replacement.... lee? anyone?  slim pickings

[GCSkiwi]

Yeah I grabbed Neade, I reckon Lee could be a good target later in the season...

[Hagebear]

I would have to say Neade as there are plenty of Magpie stars to come back into that lineup.Hitchcock is the only threat to neade's position.

And Hitchcock didn't do too much for Glenelg on the weekend.

[tbagrocks]

Robbie Gray ;)

But Nead's pressure they will want to keep, and he's exciting for the fans, I recon he gets a good go at it

[FisherSaints]

Neade has more JS, as others have said. Dwyer will be out by Rd. 6