Please rate my team VERY DIFFERENT

[Carltonblues5]

Please rate my team I am pretty happy with it but I'm not sure about the mids I would like some suggestions

[back men:B.Goddard, G.Birchall,N.Maxwell, S.Gilbert, M.Jamison, N.Vlastuin,(S.Docherty, J.Frost)

Midfield: T.Cotchin, J. McVeigh, D. Rich, B. Moloney, D.Armfield, R.Crowley, L. Ball, L.Whitfield, (S. Colquhoun, C.Mooney)

Ruck men J.Roughead, M.Jamar, (M.Daw, D. Currie)

forwards: L.Franklin, S.Johnson, D.Martin, T.Cloke, J.Cameron, J.Kennedy, (J.Neade, L.Mcbean)

Salary cap: 22,800

[Rowan1812]

Yuk. You clearly have no idea about supercoach

[monga77]

Backs- maxwell Gilbert Jamison all need to go
Mids- couple of suggestions, there is a little bald headed bloke that plays for gold coast! There's a few from collingwood that go alright too
Rucks- jamar an interesting pick
Fwds- look good but jezza Cameron, could find someone better for his price

[Pkbaldy]

Wowza, you need a bit of help here chief... Different CAN be good but in this case... No i'm sorry no...

Defence: Maxwell, Gilbert and Jamison GONE please... And pick up a Gibbs, Shaw or Duffield and 2 rookies... Plenty of defender rookies SHOULD get a load of games this year

Mid: I'm sorry but Ablett, Pendles/Swan are pretty much a must in all teams if you wanna get anywhere near the button... Cotchin is good, McVeigh can be a half decent pick... But Armfield ( Played one good game) and Crowley should be downgraded to other rookies such as Viney, Crouch, O'Meara, Wines, Mitchell... All going to make you heaps. Rich and Moloney are good picks though...

Rucks: Roughie is a good pod, but i'm not a big fan of the Jamar hopefully work some money around and be able to afford Jacobs or something..

Forwards: Only thing i'd change is Cameron for Varcoe... Easy money and if you can swap one of the others for Rockliff... He is going to be a big cash cow this year and you'd be a fool to miss out!

Overall: Pretty average team... You can do a few small changes to make it MUCH MUCH better so i suggest fiddling around with your defence and midfield to maximize your team out! 6/10

[RICK05]

Agree with pkbaldy totally different is good but this team is just to way out there delete and start again 3/10