Royalzs-With-Cheese V3: rate for Rate <need help>

[nightwalker_1310au]

Royalz-With-Cheese
   
Back line: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, P.Duffield,  S.Atley, L.Stevenson, B.Goodes.
Reserves:
(D.Terlich, S.Docherty)

Mid: D.Swan, M.Murphy, K.Jack, L.Shuey, H.Bennell, J.O'meara, B.Crouch, K.Mitchell.
Reserves:
(J.Viney,  D.Towers)

Rucks: S.Jacobs, T.Bellchambers
Reserves:
(D.Currie, S.Rowe)

Forwards: T.Rockliff, D.Cox, M.Wright,  M.De Boer, J.Kennedy, P.Karnezis.
Reserves:                     
(J.Neade, S.Dwyer)

[big_cox21]

nice solid even spread. here is my concern

it reminds me of a team that I would of made when I first started play sc. too even.

you have 14 players you would want to be keepers, plus kennedy and atley.

but of the players you would want to be 'keepers', probably only 9 of the 14 will finih top 10 t their position

the ones that wont would be shuey bennell belly wright deboer. its ok to have 1 or 2 of these guys as potential break out players but your putting too much money into players you wont want in your team come round 23. pick one of shuey or bennell ditch atley and one of wright de boar. turn shuey/bennell, into molony/rookie and upgrade the one of wright/deboer. belly is alright he could explode. atley to a rookie too and then see what you have and how much cash you have.

hope that's good help. had to rush what I was saying. any questions I will keep track of the thread :)

[kma07]

Solid team.

Defence - No complaints there. I was thinking of Duffield or Hanley for mine.  But went with Hanley due to his decent start.
I like Atley as a POD.

Mids - I'd turn one of Shuey or Bennell into Fyfe/Mundy.  Fyfe is too cheap for his output and I reckon Mundy will do pretty well this season.

Ruck - No complaints

Fwd - Not too bad.  Maybe you can try change Wright/De Boer to Tex.

[colmullet]

its looking ok man, i do agree with a lot of what big_cox21 had to say though, when picking premiums you want guys who you believe will be in the top bracket of their postion come the end of the year....for breakout guys you either want them to become keepers (Bennel/Atley/Jack/Shuey/Bellchambers/Wright/De Boer) or you want guys who are starting low enough that they will make you cash (Kennedy/Karnezis)

I like the Kennedy/Karnezis selections but the others you will need a lot of things to go right for them to all be true keepers in their positions and come the finals if you have these guys up against teams full of GAJ/Pendles/Cotchin/Danger/Maric/Buddy/Tex/Pav/Shaw/Waters i don't think your team will stack up to well deeper into the season.