Rate My Team

Started by Mattb17, March 08, 2013, 01:57:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mattb17


Def: B, Gibbs  S, Shaw P, Duffield   A, Mackie   S, Atley    L, Plowman (D, Terlich   S, Colquhoun)
Mid: J, Watson  P, Dangerfield  T, Cotchin  S, Mitchell  D, Hannebery  B, Moloney  J, Caddy  J, O'Meara (B, Crouch  J Viney)
Ruc: S, Jacobs  M, Pyke (S, Rowe  D, Currie)
Fwd: T, Walker  T, Hawkins  J, Kennedy   M, Nicoski  J, Patton  B, Macaffer (S, Kerridge  J, Neade)

$10,700 Left

Rowan1812

Backs: Sam shaw in defence? No goodard? Andrew Mackie? some terrible decisions there.
Mids: Too much money spent in mids. Trade 2 of caddy, hannebery and moloney to a player like mundy and get kane mitchell from port.
Rucks: Pyke wont score enough for you
Fwds: No cox or franklin will hurt. Nicoski is injury prone and inconsistent. J Patton is injured.

5/10

johnnytheboy1

#2
Def: Should that be Heath Shaw in Defence because i wouldn't recommend Sam Shaw in your team. Get Rid of Mackie & Plowman. must get Goddard into this team as he is inderpriced this year
Mids: No GAJ,Pendles, or Swan taking a high risk here Mitchell & Hanneberry are nice unique picks
Rucks: Replace Pyke with Leuey
Fwds: Would find the money to upgrade Nicoski to Cox


Suggestions downgrade Mackie to Stevenson
                                 Pyke to Leuey
                   upgrade     Nicoski to Cox
give it a 6.5/10