Nearly done! Just need some help with my rookies

[lenneth7]

Backline:
Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Heppell, Docherty, Terlich (Goodes, Van Unen)

Mids:
Ablett, Swan, Dangerfield, Cotchin, Swallow, K.Mitchell, Crouch, O'Meara (Viney, Colquhoun)

Rucks:
Jacobs, Luenburger (Currie, Rowe)

Fwds:
Franklin, Walker, Rockliff, Martin, Macaffer, Lee (Kerridge, Membrey)

$3,100 left in the CAP

Just wondering if i should downgrade a MID to afford some better rookies?

Cheers

[lenneth7]

Anyone got any advice? Rate my team??

Cheers

[Big Mac]

Downgrade Birchall/Swallow, replace colquhoun with another rookie (he won't play - too skinny) and upgrade Lee to someone like Varcoe or Karnezis. Otherwise a solid team 8/10.

[lozza71]

Not sold on heppel and goddard in the same team.
Your fowards 5,6  a bit weak.
Not sold on walker either.
Backline needs fixing. Birchall and heppel. Prefer duffield. Newman. Ev

However in saying that it might pay off as a pod. Mabey keep them.

[cortez]

Not sold on heppel and goddard in the same team.
Your fowards 5,6  a bit weak.
Not sold on walker either.
Backline needs fixing. Birchall and heppel. Prefer duffield. Newman. Ev

However in saying that it might pay off as a pod. Mabey keep them.

Whats wrong with Birchall? He scores well and consistant. And Newman... we have no idea how he will score he is a risk at best.

[tor01doc]

Love your choices of

Birchall (safe as houses and with Lake there he will run free)
Walker (up and coming gun could break out and stun them - made for SC)
Cotchin and ? A Swallow (very handy types likely to rise too)

Better rookies - time will tell. If they are named, hold onto them.

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: Very Solid
Mids: Great Midfiel  Like the unique pick of Swallow
Rucks: Good selection here
Fwds: Bit risky having Mccaffer & Lee on the field would look at upgrading either Kerridge or Lee to Varcoe

Overall your team has about 12 premiums if you include  Heppell 13. i give it an 8/10