Which collingwood superstar?

[nperera95]

HELP!

[sammy123]

i did a post lile this a few weeks back. Pendles was every ones fav
but a few said beams

[fever]

not beams over either. it's really six of one, half a dozen of the other.

[Keeper27]

doesnt really matter who you start with, both players should be in your team by years end.

[Ringo]

Pendles - Underpriced imo as average decreased due to sub fro precaution in game against GC where he had racked up 95SC points to 3/4 time.

[ubeaut]

Every year I have started with the wrong one. First i had Pendles and Swan dominated(first year just mucking around). Then I got Swan and Pendles broke out. Then last year I got Swan against my better judgement and Pendles fired straight up while Swan stalled.

End of the day I like Pendles better as a player, he has more improvement left than Swanny and he is better suited to Supercoach with his more efficient disposal.

You could go unique and pick Beams,but I prefer Pendles,more proven.

[gunnerzzz]

I read an article and linked it on here a few weeks ago where Buckley admitted Swan had lost his hunger last year, but had regained it for ''13. I wouldn't be suprised if he goes SC crazy. But in saying that, I've gone Pendles.. purely because he is younger and could go even larger than what he has in previous years.

[Ricochet]

Pendles averaged the same as Swan and played half the season with a broken leg
Have to go Pendles, he is underpriced and should score similar if not more than Swan

[quinny88]

Come on this is like the 10th time this has been posted this year  ::)

[Ricochet]

Here you are mate

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72886.0.html

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72425.0.html

[fever]

Come on this is like the 10th time this has been posted this year  ::)

absolute lock that it wont be the last either

[tor01doc]

Reading through the comments of those other threads (and this one)

The totals

Pendles 15  plus 3 honourable mentions
Swan 2 plus 1 honourable mention

Both/either - 17

So it's either BOTH or Pendles.

[Hagebear]

Ideally get both if u can for them in but if u had to choose 1 I would go with Pendles. Have a feeling he will go to another level this year.