Main Menu

Quick Rate

Started by hi fyfe, February 20, 2013, 12:30:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

hi fyfe

My team after the nab cup, a tad unique with the strategy

B: Goddard Gibbs Heppell/Hanley Pittard Docherty Stevenson     Terlin Van Unen

M: Ablett Pendlebury J.Selwood/Beams Kennedy Murphy Barlow Omearea Mitchell   Viney Crouch

R: Goldstein Leuenberger  Witts Currie

F: Cox Walker Rockliff Wright Maccaffer Neade   Lee Dick


Undecided between having Dayne Beams and Dyson Heppel or J.Selwood (or anyone below value) and Pierce Hanley
Also not that sure on Tex Walker

Rate and give your views

cheers

ubeaut

Pretty good mate. I would go Selwood and Hanley personally. I like the weak backs strategy going that way myself. I have Yarran at D4 but if there are enough good rookies then one at D4 should work. Otherwise u may have replace Barlow or someone with a rookie and get Yarran/Hanley/Heppel/Shaw at D4.

Not sold on Wright or Rockliff personally but can't fault ur other picks.

Ringo

Solid team here that will serve you well.

Defence: Solid would take Hanley over Heppell mainly for team Balance as both Essendon and Carlton share Round 13 bye and you have other Round 13 exposures as well. Even with 30 trades may be in trouble.
Mids: Solid here - Mid rookies seem to make the most cash quickly so maybe would look at downgrading Barlow to a rookie. Would take Selwood over Beams for the same reason taking Hanley.
Rucks Standard - Look at a R/F DPP for flexibility with Cox
Fwds Sound as well.  Maybe due to the absence of Forward Rookies look at getting Varcoe, Byrnes, JJ Kennedy or similar.

Rate Team 8.5/10 - Good luck