Main Menu

Please rate

Started by j, February 19, 2013, 01:26:57 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

j

Backs- Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Pearce, vlastuin, Goodes (Docherty, Stevenson)
Mids- Prendlebury, Dangerfield, Murphy, Fyfe, Gaff, Wines, Crouch, O'Meara (Mitchell, Viney)
Ruck- Cox, Leuenberger (Witts, Currie)
Forwards- Franklin, Rockliff, Darling, LeCras, Byrnes, Macaffer (Rowe, Lee)

I'm not sure bout Vlastuin at d5 but not sure who else to choose. I will trade in Ablett after  his price settles

JMAN23


Ringo

You have Gibbs twice as a defender and mid.

tor01doc


j

Ha that was supposed to be Murphy, thanks for that

tor01doc

Nice j

But Darling, who do you have at F3, and may I call you Darling?

My only serious comment is that you don't have great ruck cover if Leue gets rested.

A lot have Cox in front.

Then can use Rowe from R4 to swing forward and cover Leue.

Also no Ablett no Swan = no overall.

j

I picked Pendels over swan cos generally Prendlebury performs better in super coach and swan is better in DT, I will be trading in Ablett in for Fyfe or gaff once his price settles down. I know darling isn't the best f3 but I am sensing a big year from him, do u have any other suggestions for f3 in a similar price bracket?

tor01doc

Cox.

Christensen also potentially breaking out.

Darling KPP surely won't be consistent enough, especially when NicNat returns.

Consider Varcoe as a cheaper money maker too.

j

That's a thought . I'm not keen on Varcoe, he seems popular this year but I'm not sure why. I will keep an eye on Christensen I think you might be right bout him.

tor01doc

Varcoe = popular because underpriced (only has to score 50 + I think), has JS, has DPP which may be handy too.

j

JS?? 
What do you think of vlastuin at D5?

tor01doc

Varcoe is now a shoe in for round one - (thank you serial pest Ballantyne)  ;D

Vlastuin is going to play from what I have heard but is he worth the extra $$ for a rookie - a lot have failed to live up to the 50% loading (eg vs Terlich, Docherty, etc)

If you start him in mids you get DPP but seems nobody cares about this any more!  :(

j

Is pittard a better pick than vlastuin?

johnnytheboy1

Def: Seems to  be solid although not so sure about Pearce probably better off with Yarran or Atley at D4 leave Vlastiun in your team after what i saw of Pittard on the weekend
Mids:  Gaff could be a good POD although he is probably  better in DT probably 1 premium short here
Rucks: Move Cox to the forward line replace him with Goldstein or Jacobs Move Rowe to your Ruck Bench
Fwds: Replace Franklin with Cox you should keep only one of Darling or Le Cras
Overall You need to strengthen your midfield but apart from a few minor alterations your team should be set I give it a 7/10