ryder vs roughy

[ando_10]

title says it all tossing up for a spot in my forward line as the DPP link

[Jroo]

Roughy, he's more reliable than Ryder.

[Colliwobblers]

both goal kicking ruckmen, if ryder can stay on the park he has the higher ceiling less competition in his fwd line and more athletic.

can't go wrong i reckon both are in for strong seasons.

just bruest gunston coming through, hale stepped it up last season and then there is buddy puts me off roughy

[colmullet]

Even with all those stepping up last year, and coming off the Achillies Roughy popped out 100+ average.....now with a full pre-season you would think things would only improve from there, he's not spectacular but puts the points on the board every week, was my best pick last year

[MTTY]

I'm inclined to say Ryder but only if Bailey starts for the Hawks. The way i see it is that if Roughead isn't rucking (or barely rucking) he will have too much competition for scoring in the forwardline, whereas, although Ryder scores a lot better as a ruck, he won't have as much competition especially if Hurley plays down back.

[Hagebear]

Yeh Roughy for me. Also have him starting at the moment. Like Colmullet said had an interrupted preseason last year and still scored really well. Could be in for a big year.

[The Mongoose]

I don't know about anyone else, but for me a lot of these decisions are being made for me, due to my team composition.

In the interests of keeping a balanced team, I'm refusing to have more than three players from any one club.

At the moment I have Roughead in, but I'd rather have Ryder - which would be breaking my rule.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 Ryder, but not by much. Roughy has more competition around the forward line, Hawks have a very hard first 7 matches. An afterthought definitely Ryder. Cheers.

[quinny88]

Ryder always seems to find himself in massive form slumps. With all thats gone on at Essendon over the past few weeks I cant see them starting the season too well so I would go for Roughy

[Vincent]

You cannot go wrong with either. I'd choose Ryder but I'm not saying he'll be any better than Roughead. Draw.