Not quite there - comments please

[RoughRed]

Cash left $90.2k

Hope to get Nit Nac into the team at some point
Both Patton and Darling have performed well in NAB ... especially marking wise
Suban looks fit and silky ... should be the go to man out of defence (with Pearse) for the Dockers

Option
Gibbs to Defence
Trade out Suban
Trade Patton to Rook say $110k
This will leave $470 to $500k to put another upper end Mid

Any input appreciated

[LF]

Ok your Eagles bias really shows lol you need to put your support for the Eagles aside when playing fantasy footy.

That ruck combo is a really bad idea you need to partner Luey with a premo
Yours mids are too strong but too weak in the players that you have chosen
Gibbs should be in your defence not mids
Darling yes he could go to the next level
Patton may be a good pick in years to come but imo not yet
Martin is a risk at F3 you need a proven premo in that spot
Backs are good but you need to drop one and move Gibbs in I`d suggest Heppel or Stanley
Staker is injured
Colquhoun is not likely to play this year

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: Would Replace Stanley With Gibbs and Staker with Stevenson or Terlich downgrade Suban to Tambling or another cash cow.
Mids: Would only Keep Shuey go Priddis to A.Swallow better off having a Cash Cow at M6
make Fyfe M5.
Rucks: Need Jacobs at R1 get rid of Hannath move gorringe to the Bench
Fwds: Good unique pick in Darling should score well this year i think Patton is a year off so maybe look  at Someone like Byrnes,Pettard or Varcoe

Overall your team has problems particularly in the Ruck will give it a 7/10

[RoughRed]

Thanks for the input LuvFooty n johnnytheboy1
Still playing with the options
Just can't shake them eagle boys



Looking at the rucks/fwds
Maybe downgrade Butcher
Martin => Robinson
Downgrade Lower to Rook
Use $ to upgrade ruck
Or upgrade lower to prem

Worried about having too many rooks on the field at R1

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: You have spent too much in defencec you need to downgrade one of those as well as butcher on the forward line I hope can score as well as Moloney who is around the same price and i think will score better.
Midfield: You have 4 top premiums plus Fyfe not enough cash cows in my opinion
Ruck: You must have a  better ruckmen than Gorringe as you will lose points to people who have got 2 premiums
Fwds: Solid except for butcher who you have said you will downgrade to a cash Cow

I erate your team an 7.5/10

[Southstorm]

Defs: D1-D4 are all solid choices. Not many people have a high-mid pricer at D5 so points for uniqueness but it's not a structure I'd go with. Defenders don't score overly well and there are a lot of good rookie defs this year so I'd look at trading Heppell for a rookie and pocketing the $350k saving. Vlastuin will not play often this year and he is pretty expensive so I'd downtrade him as well.

Mids: Bit of a risk with Shuey at M4, most of the people who have him seem to put him at M5. You never know, it could pay off. Maybe look at upgrading him to somebody like Cotchin or Dangerfield. Lower is a POD. Fyfe will probably go up to $550k and Lower should also earn money, although personally I think Ball or Moloney would be a better choice. 

Ruc: Desperately needs a premium here. Upgrade Gorringe with the money you can save in defence.

Fwd: Nice structure here. Two PODs in Kennedy and Butcher. No other comments from me

All up: Solid team but I think it could do with a couple of tweaks. 7.5/10

[RoughRed]

Thanks for comments all
Will ponder a bit and watch over the weekend  :-\
Then revisions  :o