danger vs swan vs coach

Started by starz, February 08, 2013, 08:02:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who wouldn't you pick

cotchin
4 (16%)
swan
14 (56%)
dangerfield
7 (28%)

Total Members Voted: 1

starz

i'm leaning towards swan but i have a feeling he is going to go bang from the start, but i also feel that cotchin and danger are going to take their games to new levels.

they are all having good pre seasons especially swan. with their respective teams i have a feeling it might be adelaide that might struggle, but i don't have a reason why they will struggle only the fact that they lost tippet but that shoudn't effect danger too much anyway. he will probaby cop the tag which might be a bit of an issue.

cotchin is a dead set gun, the onl;y thing that might effect him is a real hard tag as he is now so well publisied as one of the best players in the comp but he seems very capable of dealing with the tag.

and swan i think will be top two again but i feel bad for some reason for starting all swan ablett and pendles.

i would start pendles swan ablett cotchin and danger but thats not exciting at all and is a waste of value in the mids.
anyway whio shouldn't i start with?
cheers

The Mongoose

#1
To be honest, these three are all absolute star players. You're really splitting some very, very fine hairs here.

When it comes down to such a decision, there's only so much you can predict. In these situations The Mongoose believes that you should go with your gut. Take the ones that you WANT to take, because at the end of the day these are all players that should, by all rights, absolutely smash the scoring.

But you're quite right. This can be seen as 'boring', as there's no point of difference mid selections there. Maybe consider a slightly cheaper premium who you think will improve, and use the cash elsewhere?

starz

im thinking of maybe starting swan and danger even though cotchin is my favourite player only due to the fact that swan and danger can go bang where as cotchin is more consistent but probably does go bang as much as the others. although im finding it hard to keep him out of my side, same with swan and danger!!!!!!!

quinny88

All stars. Dangerfield the least consistent though

tbagrocks

Quote from: starz on February 08, 2013, 08:31:25 PM
im thinking of maybe starting swan and danger even though cotchin is my favourite player only due to the fact that swan and danger can go bang where as cotchin is more consistent but probably does go bang as much as the others. although im finding it hard to keep him out of my side, same with swan and danger!!!!!!!

Me too, also JPK but we can't have them all, so many aroung the 120+ now, really anyone of them is worth it, i'm expecting a fitter Dangerman but you would think Cotchin will also be ready to step up

Just to tough, i'm thinking of avoiding Danger and Cotch just on the fact younger players can go backwards after a big breakout, and watch them and upgrade later

Jay

Swan is on a different SC level to those 2 at the moment but they are not far off

Gotta be Swanny at this point though

starz

I think the poll may have confused some people as its who wouldn't you pick. Not who would you pick.

Jay

Quote from: starz on February 08, 2013, 10:23:27 PM
I think the poll may have confused some people as its who wouldn't you pick. Not who would you pick.
lol yeah it confused me :-\

SydneyRox

Quote from: Jayman on February 08, 2013, 08:58:02 PM
Swan is on a different SC level to those 2 at the moment but they are not far off

Gotta be Swanny at this point though

i am confused? you woukdnt pick swan?

cotchin is #3 of these guys

nrich102

Why wouldnt you want to pick swan?

Jay

Quote from: SydneyRox on February 09, 2013, 02:12:10 AM
Quote from: Jayman on February 08, 2013, 08:58:02 PM
Swan is on a different SC level to those 2 at the moment but they are not far off

Gotta be Swanny at this point though

i am confused? you woukdnt pick swan?

cotchin is #3 of these guys
Meant Swan is the pick of them

Danger #3 for me

tor01doc