Rate My Team. :)

[pooj11]

Hey everyone, please rate my team and suggest any changes. Any help is greatly appreciated.

*******************************************************************************************
DEF: B.Goddard, B.Waters, J.Grimes, S.Atley, N.Bock, J.Pittard (Subs: S.Docherty, D.Terlich)
*******************************************************************************************
MID: G.Ablett (C), T.Cotchin (VC), M.Boyd, S.Thompson, O.Wines, B.Crouch, J.Viney, J.O'Meara (Subs: N.Hrovat, S. Colquhoun)
*******************************************************************************************
RUC: D.Hale, M.Leunenberger (Subs: B.Grundy, D.Currie)
*******************************************************************************************
FOR: L.Franklin, D.Cox, T.Rockliff, D.Petrie, G.Broughton, J.Daniher (Subs: J.Neade, T.Lee)
******************************************************************************************* 

[kilbluff1985]

Waters and Bock are to risky with injury concerns

better options then Boyd+Thompson imo

rucks Hale is super unique could work

forwards good but spending to much cash here imo

spend less money in defense/forward and get another mid and i'd ditch Boyd+Thompson for younger players

[Mat0369]

All the reports I have heard on bock is that he will not be ready for round 1, he needs to go. Better options up forward then Broughton, if you insist on having him I would have him as a defender. Those are the two major ones I saw off the top of my head, try changing those over and then it will be easier to tweak the rest.

[Colliwobblers]

bock will be lucky to be back for round 1, get him in after he plays his second game, well worth having at his price imo.

YOU MUST HAVE GIBBS.

think there are better options for SC than, Grimes, Boyd, SThompson

Hale is not strong enough for your #1 ruck i would get roughead or ryder if after DPP.

broughton did not impress tonight and i was tempted by him too but not any more especially not for SC.

daniher wont play many games? if he does will he score well as a key fwd against the AFL key defenders?

petrie is unique and looks good again this season, franklin i am dubious on but he is elite pay for him now or later i guess.

rocky and cox i like, ablett is a must cotchin should be good, waters is good atley will be good - but when?

colquhoun is tiny dont think he will play much with wines and kane mitchell more afl ready, think daw is more likely to pinch hit and play fwd than currie is,

good start, i would do a little work on it, good luck in 2013.

[tbagrocks]

I agree with everything CW said except Mitchell as he will find it hard to make the 22

[pooj11]

Thanks guys, but can you give me more info on who to get in instead of players who you all told me to take out, i m not that experienced, this is only my second year of doing SC

[Colliwobblers]

havent got time right now but this is a good looking side, i like a deeper midfield myself and a lighter defence but this is your genuine well balanced SC team

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71466.0/topicseen.html - the last updated posted team :)

[Mat0369]

Russell or Varcoe instead of Bock. So if you switch Broughton back for Bock bring in Varcoe forward, if you leave Broughton forward, try Russell