Ormos/Siralo Supercoach Team - Input Welcome

[Ormos]

2013 is upon us already, time to start getting my SC brain ticking over.

First attempt, rookies as always will be adjusted after NAB cup.

DEF
GODDARD, GIBBS, BROUGHTON, STAKER, PITTARD, DOCHERTY
R - GOODES, COLQUHOUN

MIDFIELDERS
ABLETT, PENDLEBURY, COTCHIN, MUNDY, ZIEBELL, MOLONEY, BALL, VINEY
R - O’MEARA, COWAN

RUCK
MUMFORD,LEUENBERGER
R - WITTS, SINCLAIR

FWD
RYDER, ROCKLIFF, ROBINSON, MARTIN, LECRAS, VARCOE
R - MACAFFER, LEE

[Ormos]

oh and i have $19,300 leftover

[johnnytheboy1]

Def : You are a bit light here  i think you need a Jack Grimes or Hamish Hartlett into this defence and  one less rookie
Mids Too many Mid Pricers you need at least one extra cash cow such as Crouch or Wines
Rucks Solid
Fwds If you are going to have ryder up forward then you need a DPP in the Ruck but i see you have that with Callum Sinclair who won't get a game this year.
The Only other query i have Here is Mitch Robinson i prefer either walker or wright from the crows before him

I give your team an 8/10

[Ormos]

Done a bit of a tweak to even out my lines as think was a bit heavy on the midpricers before. New team below -

DEF
GODDARD, GIBBS, BROUGHTON, GRIMES, PITTARD, DOCHERTY
R - THURLOW, COLQUHOUN

MIDFIELDERS
ABLETT, PENDLEBURY, COTCHIN, MUNDY, SWALLOW, K.MITCHELL, BALL, VINEY
R - O’MEARA, COWAN

RUCK
MUMFORD,LEUENBERGER
R - WITTS, SINCLAIR

FWD
RYDER, ROCKLIFF, ROUGHHEAD, STAKER, LECRAS, VARCOE
R - MACAFFER, LEE

$29,200 left

[Pkbaldy]

Defence: Pretty good backline... I like Grimes, but i wont be choosing him myself as he too much of an injury risk for me.
1.5/2

Midfield: Very strong midfield, Not sure which Swallow you're talking about? Gold Coast one? If so i don't really recommend him yet. Prefer you to make more room for someone like his brother.
1.5/2

Rucks: I wouldn't trust Mummy as of yet... Change to Goldstein, Maric, McEvoy or Cox. They will get you 100s nearly every week!
1.5/2

Forwards: This is where i think you fall off scale a bit.. Ryder I do not recommend at all! You dont have a link between ruck and forward line and there are much better options for that price! You'd want either Buddy or Cox as your F1. As for Lecras and Varcoe, i think you should only get 1 for the injury risk they both probably still hold.
1/2

Uniqueness: Fairly unique with either Swallow you've got even though i'd prefer Andrew... Grimes could prove to be promising and the same with Roughead!

1.5/2

Overall: 7/10 Pretty good, you just need to try wither down on those injury prone players and prepare for the NAB Cup with your Rookies! Good luck mate

[Frozensage]

Done a bit of a tweak to even out my lines as think was a bit heavy on the midpricers before. New team below -

DEF
GODDARD, GIBBS, BROUGHTON, GRIMES, PITTARD, DOCHERTY
R - THURLOW, COLQUHOUN

MIDFIELDERS
ABLETT, PENDLEBURY, COTCHIN, MUNDY, SWALLOW, K.MITCHELL, BALL, VINEY
R - O’MEARA, COWAN

RUCK
MUMFORD,LEUENBERGER
R - WITTS, SINCLAIR

FWD
RYDER, ROCKLIFF, ROUGHHEAD, STAKER, LECRAS, VARCOE
R - MACAFFER, LEE

$29,200 left

Both ryder and roughhead are ruc/fwd. Maybe put one of them in Ruc and drop Mumford? Then you have the link cover.

[Ormos]

Well had the weekend to do some reading, playing around and thinking.

Have swaped in cox, and changed mummy to jacobs (not sure on him yet) as well as swapping lecras for byrnes who i think will do well at melb and has security. Only issue i have atm is i have to much $$$ leftover.


DEF
GODDARD, GIBBS, BROUGHTON, GRIMES, PITTARD, DOCHERTY
R - THURLOW, COLQUHOUN

MIDFIELDERS
ABLETT, PENDLEBURY, COTCHIN, MUNDY, SWALLOW, K.MITCHELL, BALL, VINEY
R - O’MEARA, COWAN

RUCK
JACOBS,LEUENBERGER
R - WITTS, SINCLAIR

FWD
COX, ROCKLIFF, ROUGHHEAD, STAKER, BYRNES, VARCOE
R - MACAFFER, LEE

$72,500 left